NESSAholics.com

Other Topics => Entertainment - Movies / TV / Books => Topic started by: JazzyManda on December 14, 2003, 11:50:38 am

Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on December 14, 2003, 11:50:38 am
here we go again. starts in January i think. i just saw a comercial for it. lol


Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on December 14, 2003, 12:00:32 pm
I excited for it! The auditions are the best part of the show! They're hilarious!!
I'm also excited because I know a bunch of people who tried out!
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on December 14, 2003, 12:01:30 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
I excited for it! The auditions are the best part of the show! They're hilarious!!
I'm also excited because I know a bunch of people who tried out!


i know! i love the auditions. they're too funny.

you know people who tried out??!! that's so cool!

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on December 14, 2003, 03:48:33 pm
the auditions are hilarious!!!!! haha... i love watchin them.

But the show itself.. is so addicting, I'm so obsessed with it and i' wicked excited for the new season.

(this thread prolly will get locked or moved.... to movies/shows or whatever cuz i know theres an AI thread there.)  :D  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on December 14, 2003, 03:52:22 pm
yea i was thinking that (your last comment), gi.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Vultch on December 14, 2003, 03:56:36 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
(this thread prolly will get locked or moved.... to movies/shows or whatever cuz i know theres an AI thread there.)  :D  :D

I moved it, but I did a search and didnt see any exactly for AI, some for auditions and so forth, so its all good I think. If I'm wrong and there is another, another mod can lock.
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on December 14, 2003, 04:08:45 pm
Quote
(this thread prolly will get locked or moved.... to movies/shows or whatever cuz i know theres an AI thread there.)


lol. woops

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on December 14, 2003, 04:34:27 pm
woo hoo! let the cringing begin! i always get so embarrased for the people trying out that are really really bad, but want to go to hollywood so badly.
Title: American Idol
Post by: CaliGirl20 on December 15, 2003, 12:58:05 am
I was supposed to audition, but was out of town the weekend it happened in LA. Oh well....lol  At elast I saved myself the embarrassment of being on TV in front of millions of viewers.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Blake on December 15, 2003, 01:40:23 am
Ohhh NOOO!!!

*not another radio bomb sucks ass song! and album from someone sad like KC, CA, RS, JG,*

Although the first episode is funny, only thing worth watching, other than simon.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on December 15, 2003, 05:26:45 am
shush dm, i love american idol!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 19, 2004, 09:42:59 am
oops, I dont know which of these I'm supposed to use... but in any case...

AMERICAN IDOL 3 STARTS TONITE AND I'M FREEKIN EXCITED :wink:

(someone maybe inform me which i should use haha...)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Manda on January 19, 2004, 10:19:06 am
I saw the commercial too.

I only watch the first couple of episode's were people try and sing and they look awfully funny.

after that, I dont watch it....

;)

not a big fan of the show.

Manda
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on January 19, 2004, 10:31:08 am
first new episode is on tonight people!!

lol

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 19, 2004, 11:35:28 am
damn right :razz:   8)   :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on January 19, 2004, 01:43:25 pm
Ooo I can watch it on the *new* tv i got today! woot! oh my, i saw a  preview for it on ET on MTV and i felt so bad for this little chinese guy who sang a Ricky Martin song and he had no idea how bad he was. he looked so crushed  :(  I always feel bad for those people, because they want it so bad. hahaha there was a clip of this guy who got so mad he spilled water all over Simon!! LMAO...erm, sorry for the spoilers  :oops:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 19, 2004, 02:50:11 pm
hahaha... i think its funny though cuz like... everyone knows how mean they can be, so why would u even go to it if you weren't prepared to possibly get ripped apart.  Its such amusing television lol... im soooo psyched for the WHOLE season tho.. i get SO addicted :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on January 19, 2004, 03:25:18 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
hahaha... i think its funny though cuz like... everyone knows how mean they can be, so why would u even go to it if you weren't prepared to possibly get ripped apart.  Its such amusing television lol... im soooo psyched for the WHOLE season tho.. i get SO addicted :D


omg, i know. i like start rooting for this person through out the show and then they usually get voted off like in the 4th round and then i'm like "oh, i hate this show  :evil: " and then i like skip an episode, then watch the next one and get hooked again. lol. this time i'm going to try and watch the whole season.  
Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 19, 2004, 03:58:45 pm
LoL... i'm just hooked from day 1, i was rooting for Clay, Kimberly Caldwell and Kimberly Locke last season, they all made it pretty far :wink:  hehe.. two of them being in the top 3.  One more hour... yay!
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on January 19, 2004, 04:03:43 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
LoL... i'm just hooked from day 1, i was rooting for Clay, Kimberly Caldwell and Kimberly Locke last season, they all made it pretty far :wink:  hehe.. two of them being in the top 3.  One more hour... yay!


yeah, i was chearing for the blonde Kimberly (can't remember last name)
and then she got voted off and i was all mad.... but then i just forgot about her and was like "yeah Ruben!!" lol  

1 more hour for me too. the first episodes are the best. they're sooooo funny. can't wait! hehe

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 19, 2004, 04:29:31 pm
Kimberly Caldwell is the one you were cheerin for.  I really liked her!
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on January 19, 2004, 05:18:22 pm
man, that girl in the air born division should have gotten to go. i thought she was really good

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on January 21, 2004, 06:11:24 pm
Hahaha... the auditions in Houston were terrible... oh man :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on January 21, 2004, 06:20:15 pm
they were awful! the only thing i don't understand is why they didn't show more of the people who got it. i mean, i understand that the bad ones and the bantering get more air time, but at the same time i'd like to kind of see what's to come,  you know?

LMAO, the guy who threw the water at Simon!  ROFL
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on January 22, 2004, 05:34:27 pm
Houston was pretty bad but the funniest. lol

and yeah, i wish they had shown more people who made it

Amanda
Title: American Idol favorites
Post by: JazzyTim on January 28, 2004, 03:30:56 pm
lol , I was just wondering, for those of you who watched American Idol last not who you liked the best, or thought was the funniest,
personally I thought Mr. William Hung was hilarous,lol

Tim :lol:
Title: Re: American Idol favorites
Post by: Holly on January 28, 2004, 06:07:03 pm
Quote from: "JazzyTim"
lol , I was just wondering, for those of you who watched American Idol last not who you liked the best, or thought was the funniest,
personally I thought Mr. William Hung was hilarous,lol

Tim :lol:


yes he was! lol

I think my fave guy last night was the guy who's parents came from indo china! he was GOOD!
Also Jasmin! She was so good  cute and her personality shined through! Actually when I first saw her on camera she didnt even look like a dwarf to me. But yeah, i hope she makes it!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 10, 2004, 06:13:21 pm
i loooooooooove fantasia! she'll definately be movin on to the next round, as for the other one, i dono who it'll be.  I dont like the guy they compared to clay, thought he sucked. GRR
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on February 10, 2004, 06:15:37 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
i loooooooooove fantasia! she'll definately be movin on to the next round, as for the other one, i dono who it'll be.  I dont like the guy they compared to clay, thought he sucked. GRR


She's from the same ciiiity that I was born in/live beside!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Blake on February 10, 2004, 07:08:03 pm
On one of the local morning shows today they played that william hung dude (she bangs)? with HEY YA! as the background..And they included his talking at the end, it was Hillarious!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Dancernl on February 10, 2004, 09:26:22 pm
I liked Marque and Fantasia, and the one who sang the jazz piece.  I usually don't vote until the top ten though, I'd use too many minutes on my cell!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 11, 2004, 06:05:15 pm
FANTASIA! YAYYY! and Diana  :)  in the final 12 so far
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on February 11, 2004, 07:13:54 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
FANTASIA! YAYYY! and Diana  :)  in the final 12 so far


I know! both of the ones i was rooting for! if not fantasia, then marque, but i'm really happy with the two of them! diana has such an adult voice for being 16! and her name is the same as my mom's :-P
Title: First group
Post by: babyblue43402 on February 11, 2004, 07:43:18 pm
I'm sorry but i thought these first 8 were a lot better then most of the top ten last year....wow they were all really talented! i can't wait to watch the rest. Fantasia and Diane were awesome!
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on February 11, 2004, 07:46:06 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Gina"
FANTASIA! YAYYY! and Diana  :)  in the final 12 so far


I know! both of the ones i was rooting for! if not fantasia, then marque, but i'm really happy with the two of them! diana has such an adult voice for being 16! and her name is the same as my mom's :-P


booooo for Diana..I didn't like her....

I liked the gal that covered Patsy's "crazy"....and YAY for my HOMETOWN gal FANTASIA!!!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on February 12, 2004, 07:18:22 am
Yay for Diana - my hometown girl - i thought she was really good!
Title: American Idol
Post by: xxjenniferxx on February 12, 2004, 04:02:13 pm
she bang she bang
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on February 12, 2004, 04:03:34 pm
Quote from: "xxjenniferxx"
she bang she bang


lol

dude: i have no professional training
simon: no way!! (sarcastic)

that's my fave part of the whole show this year
haha

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on February 14, 2004, 04:19:05 am
crap I haven't been watchin it....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 17, 2004, 04:36:25 pm
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
crap I haven't been watchin it....


tsk tsk!  :D  It's on tonite!
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on February 17, 2004, 05:04:05 pm
on right now!

i haven't watched it for like two episodes. i'm going to try and vote tonight, i've never gotten in before

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 17, 2004, 05:53:32 pm
I think Camile is the cutest thing ever.... she was kinda nervous you could tell but I want her into the next round  :)

but oh good god, most of them were TERRIBLE
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 17, 2004, 09:10:41 pm
Tonight’s group wasn’t that great! More like... terrible!
But I did like Lisa, Camile, and Marissa! My prediction is that they will be the top 3... And that Lisa and Camile will go through to the top 12... But I’m not usually good at predicting! I’m almost positive Camile will go to the next round though! She’s GOOD! I love her! She has an awesome voice and a spunky attitude! Lisa and Marissa are good to… so we’ll see who gets it!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Dancernl on February 17, 2004, 10:12:53 pm
Tonight I cringed a LOT!  Lisa's was the best performance I thought.  She'd better be in the top 2!
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on February 17, 2004, 10:26:01 pm
If Camile is the Velasco or whatever, I liked her voice too. I was flipping the channels and caught a few, they were really bad. The other big girl, well Simon thinks, with the gap in her teeth was ok. Not sure about that Joy chick she was ok.

At first I didn't think that that one chick looked like Sarah Jessica but she kinda did.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 17, 2004, 10:34:23 pm
Camile is the girl from Hawii who is usually (but wasnt tonight) more of a hip hop singer. She has an awesome voice!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 18, 2004, 11:55:10 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Camile is the girl from Hawii who is usually (but wasnt tonight) more of a hip hop singer. She has an awesome voice!


agreeeed!  :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on February 18, 2004, 04:58:29 pm
i didn't think any of them were that great. the last one (don't remember the name, i voted for her number though) i thought was the best. but even she wasn't that good.... i don't know. she's no Kelly. but that was only one group. i'm sure there's better people.

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 18, 2004, 06:39:46 pm
Camile :)  and Matthew...

I thought Lisa shoulda gotten picked instead of Matthew but whatever i guess.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on February 18, 2004, 07:22:32 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
Camile :)  and Matthew...

I thought Lisa shoulda gotten picked instead of Matthew but whatever i guess.


I knoooooow! I'm hoping she'll come back as a wildcard...but seriously...i thought Matthew sucked out...
Title: American Idol
Post by: Dancernl on February 18, 2004, 08:48:52 pm
I'm not thrilled with either of them.  Lisa should have gone though.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 20, 2004, 04:01:18 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
Camile :)  and Matthew...

I thought Lisa shoulda gotten picked instead of Matthew but whatever i guess.


Me too!! I really liked Lisa!
I'm not a big fan of Matthew... I think he just got picked because he's so different than all the other contestants, and they needed a guy, since the girls are kicking ass this year.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on February 20, 2004, 04:09:48 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
think he just got picked because he's so different than all the other contestants, and they needed a guy, since the girls are kicking ass this year.


LMAO, did you see him jumping with Ryan when he got picked?! Dude looked like he could have squashed him!! :-P
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 24, 2004, 06:02:24 pm
so damn, latoya london?  :D  She was FREEKIN amazing! Some other good ones too, much better than last week
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on February 24, 2004, 06:33:48 pm
bleh, i missed it. but i'll tune in tomorrow to see who wins
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 24, 2004, 09:21:11 pm
My 2 fave performances tonight were Amy and LaToya!!
Amy has such an awesome personality (you have to, inorder to pull off pink hair!) and a beautiful voice!
And LaToya is just... WOW! She is amazing!!!! She's definitely going to be one of the top 2 tomorrow, no doubt!
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on February 24, 2004, 10:46:43 pm
I can't believe I am watching this show, damn that there isn't anything on tv at 8.

The last chick was really good. The one chick who I think is like 17 her parents were singers or what not overseas, I didn't think she was that good. The one dude, he does look like Clay, poor thing. The big Hawaiian guy sucked too. The chick with the purple hair she is ok, but her hair is ugly.

Just my two cents.  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 25, 2004, 09:35:18 am
Quote from: "eclv"
The one dude, he does look like Clay, poor thing.


 :evil:  

atleast clay can sing a million times better than him... i think clays cute tho lol but thats just me, liking dorky guys :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 25, 2004, 04:34:10 pm
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 25, 2004, 04:49:56 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D


Charly  :)  Yeah her accent was cute, she had a low voice tho didn't she? hehe... but i liked her dress lots too!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 25, 2004, 04:54:15 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "Holly"
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D


Charly  :)  Yeah her accent was cute, she had a low voice tho didn't she? hehe... but i liked her dress lots too!


Oh, yes, Charly! That's what my mom wanted to name me... lol, after my dad.
yeah, i want a dress like that for my prom!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 25, 2004, 05:29:07 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "Holly"
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D


Charly  :)  Yeah her accent was cute, she had a low voice tho didn't she? hehe... but i liked her dress lots too!


Oh, yes, Charly! That's what my mom wanted to name me... lol, after my dad.
yeah, i want a dress like that for my prom!


::sigh:: prom... i'm searching everywhere for a prom dress, so stressful- but i'm incredibly excited :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 25, 2004, 06:04:36 pm
LaToya :D  and Amy are now in the final 12
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on February 26, 2004, 12:05:17 pm
yeah....i'm glad....

so far i've picked all six that got in....


Leah looked so disgusted when she didn't get picked....she'll prolly be back for the wildcard show though....
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on February 26, 2004, 02:02:55 pm
leah was NOT good at all...
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on February 26, 2004, 05:09:42 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
leah was NOT good at all...


eh...she wasn't all that bad....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on February 26, 2004, 05:29:18 pm
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
leah was NOT good at all...


eh...she wasn't all that bad....


She wasn't great, but she wasn't terrible.... IDK.  She sorta annoyed me though for some reason.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 26, 2004, 07:45:15 pm
I'm SO happy that Amy and Latoya are in the top 12 now!! As I said, those were my 2 faves from the group!  :D
LaToya has a voice that amazes me everytime.
Amy has a beautiful voice and her sweet, spunky personality shines through even when she sings. It makes me smile when she performs!
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on February 26, 2004, 07:50:17 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "Holly"
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D


Charly  :)  Yeah her accent was cute, she had a low voice tho didn't she? hehe... but i liked her dress lots too!


Oh, yes, Charly! That's what my mom wanted to name me... lol, after my dad.
yeah, i want a dress like that for my prom!


I'd like to point out we don't all talk like that.

though some do...

okay...yea.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on February 26, 2004, 09:32:31 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "Holly"
O! I loved the girls dress who's from North Carolina! The girl with the cute accent! She was wearing a pink dress... SOOOO cute!!! I want it!  :D


Charly  :)  Yeah her accent was cute, she had a low voice tho didn't she? hehe... but i liked her dress lots too!


Oh, yes, Charly! That's what my mom wanted to name me... lol, after my dad.
yeah, i want a dress like that for my prom!


I'd like to point out we don't all talk like that.

though some do...

okay...yea.


awww... but it's cute!! :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 04, 2004, 06:35:52 pm
I'm SO happy Jasmine and redheaded John are in the top 12! I loved them the most out of group 4!
Jasmine has a beautiful voice and a great personality
John has a unique voice with great style! Plus, he just seems so sweet!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 05, 2004, 04:31:42 am
i think George was way better than redhead John....i'm glad he's back in for the wild card
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 05, 2004, 12:39:19 pm
Quote from: "BWilli"
i think George was way better than redhead John....i'm glad he's back in for the wild card


Agreed.
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 05, 2004, 06:34:05 pm
AI3, hmm, the only people I've really liked since the beginning are Eric Yoder, Elizabeth LaTendre, Amy Adams, and Jon Peter Lewis. As long as they make it, I'm happy.

I wasn't impressed with Leah LaBelle, Matt Rogers, John Stevens, or LaToya London at all.

And I hate how they've wasted so much time on the William Hung thing, it wasn't even funny to me.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 09, 2004, 05:55:36 pm
Wildcard show tonite :) ... right now actually hehe
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 10, 2004, 06:33:00 pm
so um.. jon peter lewis? WTF... hahaha thats such a joke, seriously.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 10, 2004, 06:38:48 pm
and that Leah girl...now THAT is the joke.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 10, 2004, 06:57:54 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
so um.. jon peter lewis? WTF... hahaha thats such a joke, seriously.


WHAT?! i missed it tonight. that's so......grrr! If any of the guys should have gotten it, it should have been george, hands down.

leah was okay....but if i had to pick someone, it would be the girl who went last.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 10, 2004, 07:36:27 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Gina"
so um.. jon peter lewis? WTF... hahaha thats such a joke, seriously.


WHAT?! i missed it tonight. that's so......grrr! If any of the guys should have gotten it, it should have been george, hands down.

leah was okay....but if i had to pick someone, it would be the girl who went last.


she made it, too.
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 10, 2004, 09:52:41 pm
I <3 the redhead boy ! He better win DAMNIT! :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 11, 2004, 05:00:46 am
nah...George Huff is the man....but i think it's gonne be a girl this year....
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 11, 2004, 06:47:36 am
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
and that Leah girl...now THAT is the joke.
Oh I'm glad somebody else said that, she is absolute trash. She looks like a druggie, Crack is Whack!
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 11, 2004, 07:49:27 am
whatever the girl's name is that's last name is hudson - disgusts me --- I cannot stand her!!!!! It's her expression when she is singing it's way a million times worse than what clay used to do - clay didn't ever disgust me..... I about threw up when they announced her name - randy dawg - that was wrong - i really never ever wanted to see her sing again (the outfits are nasty and the eye make-up is such trash!!! - she has such a scary expression on her face when she sings..... UCK!!!!) I thought the other girl with the bright blue eye shadow and the mini-fro was way cute and a better performer --- and i thought paula would pick the cute guy because girls need a heartthrob and he's clays friend - i also thought the katie girl would make it through because she has star quality and was already good on popstars or whatever (never watched that season i guess - cause no clue who she is - but always hear that gossip)

anyway - that's my rant!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 11, 2004, 09:24:31 am
Quote from: "divasteph"
whatever the girl's name is that's last name is hudson - disgusts me --- I cannot stand her!!!!! It's her expression when she is singing it's way a million times worse than what clay used to do - clay didn't ever disgust me..... I about threw up when they announced her name - randy dawg - that was wrong - i really never ever wanted to see her sing again (the outfits are nasty and the eye make-up is such trash!!! - she has such a scary expression on her face when she sings..... UCK!!!!) I thought the other girl with the bright blue eye shadow and the mini-fro was way cute and a better performer --- and i thought paula would pick the cute guy because girls need a heartthrob and he's clays friend - i also thought the katie girl would make it through because she has star quality and was already good on popstars or whatever (never watched that season i guess - cause no clue who she is - but always hear that gossip)

anyway - that's my rant!


lol   i agree with the whole facial expressions of that chick...however she can sing.....she wont win though.....i think Fantasia (is that her name) may get a lot further, but i dont know
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 11, 2004, 11:28:12 am
*shudders* that girl makes me cringe - gives me hope for becoming a pop star someday if that girl can make the top 12.....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on March 11, 2004, 12:03:57 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
and that Leah girl...now THAT is the joke.

I KNOW! Jake Simpson sang "Let's Stay Together" SO much better than her.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 11, 2004, 12:12:48 pm
I like George a lot, and I really dont like Jennifer Hudson is that bad, yes she could tone down the facials a little though... and Leah- eek.  Jon Peter Lewis honestly can't really sing well.  

I looove Fantasia, still :D  and LaToya and Camille and Jasmine

Did anyone else think that Suzy should have gotten it over Jon or Leah? Cuz I know I did.
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 11, 2004, 12:25:33 pm
i just really like deanna - BEST!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 11, 2004, 12:35:11 pm
Quote from: "divasteph"
i just really like deanna - BEST!


Diana? . . .
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 11, 2004, 12:40:28 pm
Quote from: "divasteph"
Yay for Diana - my hometown girl - i thought she was really good!


thats what i meant - brain lapse!
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 16, 2004, 05:29:08 pm
Matthew Rogerst trying to sing the Black Crows......

first off, i want to know how the hell he got on the top 12.

and secondly.....must....turn....channel.

The Black Crows are awesome, and he has officially ruined the song for me  :evil:  I hate to say it, but i'm agreeing with everything Simon is saying about him right now
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 16, 2004, 06:56:25 pm
Fantashia!!!!!

WOOOOOO!!!

High Point on the T.V. lol... "welcomes market visitors"...

though her grandma is not like the mother of High Point, cuz I don't have a clue who she is....

but I ate that restaurant she was in just last saturday!! (Golden Corral) lol.
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on March 16, 2004, 07:00:52 pm
i'm voting for Diana

woohoo

or maybe John, he's cool. he's a jazz man  :wink:

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on March 16, 2004, 07:02:10 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Matthew Rogerst trying to sing the Black Crows......

first off, i want to know how the hell he got on the top 12.

and secondly.....must....turn....channel.

The Black Crows are awesome, and he has officially ruined the song for me  :evil:  I hate to say it, but i'm agreeing with everything Simon is saying about him right now


yeah, he was pretty bad. and he has the worst attitude. he's like "i'm afraid of Simon" oh get over it. maybe you just suck? jeesh

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 16, 2004, 07:08:03 pm
ok so i hate jon peter lewis, and leah sucked... and i dont like matt rogers and i think that john stevens is so wrong for the competition, he can sing but i seriously wanted to fall asleep.

soo i love Fantasia still, I really like Jasmine, Camile too, and LaToya was good (a little overdone), and i still think that George is good, definately the best guy!  And suprisingly (to me), Diana did well.
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 16, 2004, 08:18:21 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Matthew Rogerst trying to sing the Black Crows......
That's not an original Black Crows song, they remade it. That song is really old, from the early 70s.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 17, 2004, 04:47:47 am
I loved diana's song! And George's! Other than John Peter Lewis, Matthew Rogers, and Leah, i think everyone's doing an awesome job! LMAO, next week is country, that should be interesting :-P
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 17, 2004, 05:35:43 am
well.....with the exception of Leah and John Stevens it was a great show....those two were just terrible........George, Jasmine and Diana were the best though...........
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyTim on March 17, 2004, 03:18:55 pm
best and top 3, George, Jasmine, Diana, have any of you noticed how many high schoolers there are this year! wow! im such a slacker :roll: but that's ok :wink:

Tim
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 17, 2004, 04:43:15 pm
well, if that is who you think will be the top 3, I won't ask for your suggestion in musical artist.

 8O
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 17, 2004, 06:32:53 pm
Leah's gone! i'm happy, because i can't see her as the american idol. there's just something about her that seems very catty, like she knows that she's good and isn't afraid to boast about it, you know? but if i had to pick, i would have picked mat rogers to go. i just can't stand the guy.

and i've been thinking about john stevens, and g is right, he isn't right for the competition. not because i don't think he's a good singer, becuse i think he's an excellent singer, but because his style's different than everyone else's, you know? and it also helps that he's so cute. i have a thing for red hair  :oops:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 17, 2004, 06:32:55 pm
so leahs gone, thank god.. but the top 3 was a lil whack in my opinion.

CLAYYYY PERFORMED SOLITAIRE YAYYY! I :heart: him
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 17, 2004, 09:51:51 pm
i'm glad Leah got booted, like Jessica said, she seems catty! She seems a lil full of herself, and she's not that great, her voice is kinda boring and flat.

as for the other contestants:
LaToya- She wasn’t as amazing as she normally was last night and didn’t really stick out, but she still has an awesome voice! I like her!
Matthew- He’s got a good voice, but he’s too much of a ham, and that annoys me!
John Stevens- Ok, I love this guy! Haha. He seems to have a totally sweet and cool personality. I love his style! He’s unique and adds flavor to the competition! He’s also the best dancer by far of the guys
George- Oh my goodness… I love him too! He’s like a big cuddly teddy bear and every time I see him perform I have the urge to hug him! Haha. He has a GREAT voice too! He did amazingly last night!
John Peter Lewis- he’s so adorable! He’s funny, he makes me smile every time he performs. He’s got a great voice and a funky style. He’s kinda dorky… but in a really cute way!
Diana- Wow, she’s been one of my faves from the beginning. She has a powerful voice and a totally sweet personality!
Camille- I normally love Camille, but last night the song wasn’t working for her! She’s still awesome though!
Jasmine- WOW!! Definitely the star of last night!! She killed it! Her voice is incredible!!
Jennifer- She’s got such a powerful and soulful voice, I think she’s great!
Fantasia- This girl has got a unique voice and a funky style! I like her!
Amy- She’s one of my faves too… I love her spunky personality! And her voice is just SO sweet! She’d be someone I’d want to hang out with.

As you can see… I judge by personality just as much as talent. I guess that’s cause I’m only fans of people with good personalities. Lol.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on March 17, 2004, 10:17:22 pm
I have found something else to watch, thank God. But I do flip on the commercials sometimes. I don't know all their names but I am with Holly on the big country guy, ew, can't stand him. I think a lot of them can't sing, it's really sad. The red head kid, ew too. I always thought that Leah chick couldn't sing. She is the one who's mom was a pop star in some other country right? The little guy with the gap in his teeth, he's kinda cute in his own little way. I haven't seen him sing in awhile so I can't really say. The others I haven't heard sing either so that's all for now I guess.

I HAD to change it when Clay was on, ew!! I listened to like a few seconds and he sounded terrible. Maybe it got better but what I heard was terrible. Oh, and does anyone else get annoyed when they say American Idol, Clay Aiken cause he so didn't win. WTH?

Just my few cents.  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 18, 2004, 12:12:26 pm
holls, the red hair kid is the best dancer??

that john peter dude is a horrible dancer lol, he got it from his dad.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on March 18, 2004, 12:18:38 pm
I am so glad that Leah's gone. Jake Simpson was WAY better at "Let's Stay Together".
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 18, 2004, 01:13:11 pm
Quote from: "eclv"


I HAD to change it when Clay was on, ew!! I listened to like a few seconds and he sounded terrible. Maybe it got better but what I heard was terrible. Oh, and does anyone else get annoyed when they say American Idol, Clay Aiken cause he so didn't win. WTH?


how rude... I thought Clay sounded pretty good last night, not his BEST but I adore him.  And he IS the real American Idol, which is made clear by album sales, and his popularity.  

And as for the John Stevens guy, yes he has a good voice for the type of music he sings, but he's so wrong for the competition, and I personally find him boring.  but that's just me.

And Jon Peter Lewis.. how can you guys like him.. he's really not that talented.  He kind of annoys me.... :?
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 18, 2004, 01:19:44 pm
lol, i don't know what it is about john stevens! :-P

holly i pretty much agree with your list!
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on March 18, 2004, 03:58:08 pm
well, i agree with Gina on John Stevens. he's not right for this kind of competition. but, i do think he's really talented. i think he'll go next week because well, next week is country, and i really doubt he can sing country.lol. but, i do respect how he likes to sing Frank Sanatra (sp?) kind of music, that's kind of dying out now. it's not the type of jazz i like, i like more instrumental jazz rather than having a singer being the feature of the band, but the type he sings is still good music. i think he could get a record deal with a jazz record company. but, i highly doubt he'll win.

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on March 18, 2004, 05:06:10 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "eclv"


I HAD to change it when Clay was on, ew!! I listened to like a few seconds and he sounded terrible. Maybe it got better but what I heard was terrible. Oh, and does anyone else get annoyed when they say American Idol, Clay Aiken cause he so didn't win. WTH?


how rude... I thought Clay sounded pretty good last night, not his BEST but I adore him.


did anyone else laugh when they read that? I totally heard the voice of Michelle Tanner (Mary-Kate/Ashley Olsen's role in "Full House")Haha That's cool you like him, like I said what I heard was not good. But as I always say everyone has their own tastes. *hug*
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 18, 2004, 05:11:47 pm
i didn't hear it, i turned the channel.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on March 18, 2004, 05:13:18 pm
damn, I am showing my age again. Sorry you probably never saw that show.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 18, 2004, 05:23:54 pm
Quote from: "eclv"
damn, I am showing my age again. Sorry you probably never saw that show.


nope, I love the show...I grew up on it, well I kinda missed the first couple of years...but still.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 18, 2004, 05:27:19 pm
Quote from: "eclv"
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "eclv"


I HAD to change it when Clay was on, ew!! I listened to like a few seconds and he sounded terrible. Maybe it got better but what I heard was terrible. Oh, and does anyone else get annoyed when they say American Idol, Clay Aiken cause he so didn't win. WTH?


how rude... I thought Clay sounded pretty good last night, not his BEST but I adore him.


did anyone else laugh when they read that? I totally heard the voice of Michelle Tanner (Mary-Kate/Ashley Olsen's role in "Full House")Haha That's cool you like him, like I said what I heard was not good. But as I always say everyone has their own tastes. *hug*


Haha, I totally know what you mean.  That used to be my favorite show when I was little, lol.  And yes you're right, everyone has their own tastes :wink:  *hug* back
Title: American Idol
Post by: Dancernl on March 18, 2004, 05:30:13 pm
Actually Let, it was Stephanie Tanner that always said How Rude....  Michelle said "You got it dude" which rhymes with rude so you're excused.

.....And I'm a nerd  8)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 18, 2004, 05:34:24 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
holls, the red hair kid is the best dancer??


umm... yeah. out of the 4, he is! did you see them?

and on the "how rude" comment! omg! brings back memories!! my best friend and I would always say that because of that show, haha.

and on John Stevens. What's the criteria for being right for the show? It's American Idol... not pop idol, not jazz idol, not rock idol, etc. He's good at what he does and obviously a lot of people agree. Thank God there IS someone who doesnt sound like the rest of them, I like variety!
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 18, 2004, 05:59:20 pm
lol i thought he looked uncomfortable...i thought the guys shouldn't be dancing though cuz they all looked uncomfortable...

the girls looked great but they weren't in sync (lol...telling that to holly, reminds me of n*sync....uh *shuts up*)
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on March 18, 2004, 07:08:22 pm
Quote from: "Dancernl"
Actually Let, it was Stephanie Tanner that always said How Rude....  Michelle said "You got it dude" which rhymes with rude so you're excused.

.....And I'm a nerd  8)


aah, crap, you're right. I thought she did both :oops: It's been over a decade since I watched that show. Thanks for correcting me. I guess I am not as big a tv junkie as I thought. Or is it I watch too much I get confused.  :?
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 19, 2004, 06:51:02 am
Quote from: "eclv"
did anyone else laugh when they read that? I totally heard the voice of Michelle Tanner (Mary-Kate/Ashley Olsen's role in "Full House")Haha That's cool you like him, like I said what I heard was not good. But as I always say everyone has their own tastes. *hug*
Oooh Let! I loved Full House when it used to come on ABC every Friday, I think I cried on the last episode when Michelle lost her memory (and got it back  :cry: )

Good times, good times.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 19, 2004, 06:58:23 am
Quote from: "eclv"
Quote from: "Dancernl"
Actually Let, it was Stephanie Tanner that always said How Rude....  Michelle said "You got it dude" which rhymes with rude so you're excused.

.....And I'm a nerd  8)


aah, crap, you're right. I thought she did both :oops: It's been over a decade since I watched that show. Thanks for correcting me. I guess I am not as big a tv junkie as I thought. Or is it I watch too much I get confused.  :?


Acutally, if you really want to see the show again, it's shown at 9 and 9:30 pm on nickelodeon :-P
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 19, 2004, 10:19:47 am
I voted for the Mr. Stevens ;)
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 19, 2004, 11:33:25 am
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I voted for the Mr. Stevens ;)


woot!
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on March 19, 2004, 12:41:39 pm
haha, Nicole you are so crazy from MM, Cradle of Filth to that kid  :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 19, 2004, 12:46:54 pm
hey let jay d. and i were talking and he said that diana d'garmo opened for them at fort benning at the show before the one we were at... LOL - i love that chick...
Title: American Idol top 12
Post by: Dr. Pepper on March 19, 2004, 01:39:45 pm
Even though a lot of people think that this group isn't as talented, I think that they have great potential.  There are many different styles in the group and I think that once they polish their skills we will have an outstanding group.  Do you think so?
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 20, 2004, 12:57:41 am
Quote from: "eclv"
haha, Nicole you are so crazy from MM, Cradle of Filth to that kid  :roll:


don't forget the motown in my  car you didn't like and Billie Holiday :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 20, 2004, 01:34:55 am
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I voted for the Mr. Stevens ;)


yay for nicole!!

haha, my neighbor, John, seriouslylooks exactly like a younger version of John Stevens! Even though they're both about 18, John S. just looks a year or 2 older than my John. But they're both pale with firey red hair and are named John. Actually my John has pretended to be John Steven's brother and people buy it, haha. His friend went up to a girl once:
Friend: "Do you watch American Idol?"
Girl: "Omg, yes!!"
Friend: "You know that guy, John Stevens?"
Girl: "yeah!!"
Friend: "that's his little brother over there!"
Girl: "OMG!! ARE YOU SERIOUS?! Can I have your autograph?!
John just played along and gave the girl his autograph, haha.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 23, 2004, 07:16:52 pm
SIN WAGON!!  I was hoping someone would do it...I was hoping Amy, but then i was like that might hurt her...but OMG I LOVED IT!!!

her line keeps giving me the busy tone though.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 23, 2004, 10:12:55 pm
Tonight my fave was LaToya! She was amazing!! I also loved Amy, John Stevens, George, and Diana!  :D

If I had to choose, I hope Matthew is kicked off tomorrow, cause he's my least fave of the bunch.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 23, 2004, 10:17:55 pm
*calls 1-866-436-5704*

 :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 23, 2004, 10:20:32 pm
I voted for John again.. I just love his style and he covered up for not knowing the words so well. I had no idea he did until Randy mentioned it.

I want Jasmine out... she annoys me   I would not miss John Peter Lewis (sp?)  or the 30 year old looking guy.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 24, 2004, 04:53:14 am
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
SIN WAGON!!  I was hoping someone would do it...I was hoping Amy, but then i was like that might hurt her...but OMG I LOVED IT!!!

her line keeps giving me the busy tone though.


I know!! I love the Dixie Chicks, it's the only country music that i listen to. she did an awesome job!

i didn't like matt rogers, or john peter lewis. i want both of them bone before anyone else :-P
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 24, 2004, 04:59:53 am
i still can't stand Jen Hudson's expressions when she sings.....she scares me and i'd like to see here gone

George was once again very very good as was Diana, La Toya, and whoa Amy rocked last night........

Jasmine is better than she was last night.....she had one of the best performances last week so i wouldn't want to see her go just yet.

JPL is okay......Matt was alright, but he sang better other times....I didn't care for Fantasia last night and usually she's really good.

Camille wasn't too bad either, although better last week i think....

I still can't stand John Stevens....he doesn't belong in this competition.....and i think he should be next to go along with Hudson.......
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 24, 2004, 05:45:39 am
Overall, it was pretty weak show. I wasn't impressed with anyone--not even Amy or Jon Peter.

LaToya London=OVERHYPE
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 24, 2004, 08:08:18 am
ok so jennifer hudson - has toned down her scariness - but i still dont really like her - she just reminds me of her old creepiness

her hair and outfit look great though

....

diana is my fave still however - i did not like her movements --- she seemed like she had no intent with her motions (acting thing i guess) -- she needed to have a reason for why she moved - and i did not see it - but that final note ---- wow

......

the red haired guy - has a great voice - but needs a personality

.....

fantasia is very good and was very good - however i just wasnt feelin her -- and she should not get so stand-offish when she is getting constructive critisism - because it's just juvenille - i know she was partly kidding but it came off as being stupid ...

.....

camille is so cute and her brother is hott!!! however she was boring last night - very very adorable - but performance was (thumbs down) *razz*

.....
I didnt watch many others due to flipping over to ANTM

but that was my say --- for the first time i voted for AI and I voted for Diana

xoxo
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 24, 2004, 12:36:10 pm
Quote from: "keith"
LaToya London=OVERHYPE


someone speaks the truth.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on March 24, 2004, 01:32:29 pm
i voted for people I didn't want off the show. I hate LaToya. She can sing but I just don't like her. I hope JPL goes.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 25, 2004, 04:35:16 am
i dont think i'm so surprised that Matt got the boot...he sounded kinna wussy.....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 25, 2004, 04:55:57 pm
Matthew was my choice to go. but that thing he did with Simon was hilarious!!!  :lol: makes me kinda miss him now, haha
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 26, 2004, 12:05:58 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Matthew was my choice to go. but that thing he did with Simon was hilarious!!!  :lol: makes me kinda miss him now, haha


yea... I was pretty sure he would be going... He did take it well and the whole Simon thing was funny.  Good Sport :)

I <3 JS


ha
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 27, 2004, 10:48:28 am
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I <3 JS


we should from John Stevens alliance! haha.

 :D  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on March 28, 2004, 01:07:19 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I <3 JS


we should from John Stevens alliance! haha.

 :D  :wink:


haha How cool would it be if he won! :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on March 30, 2004, 05:44:44 pm
I'd stop watching the show... haha and he sucked tonite. sorry guys.  :?

Jasmine did so well... I adore her.  

Still a few more to come...  :wink:  Including my other 2 favs

edit:  So for all you Diana fans, I think she sounded pretty good tonite.  

and Fantasia, damn she brought it tonite... I :heart: that girl. . . she's incredible!

and George did wicked great, sounded damn good tonite!  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on March 31, 2004, 04:48:15 am
FINALLY....FINALLY....FINALLY....Simon has come to his senses and realized how bad John Stevens is....and it only got worse last night...

Jasmine was a lot better than last week....

Camille also did better than her previous performances....

Amy did a really good job this week again......

JPL was okay....as usual I guess.....

La Toya I like better with more upbeat songs, but she has a great voice and continued to show that last night.....

Diana was good....shouldn't be in the bottom three (even last week she shouldn't have been)

Hudson still scares me....

Fantasia was good again....but I can't see her winning it all....

George is just the man to beat....
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on March 31, 2004, 06:25:27 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
FINALLY....FINALLY....FINALLY....Simon has come to his senses and realized how bad John Stevens is....and it only got worse last night...

YES! I'm glad somebody else on here said that! He has sucked consistantly all three weeks, yet everyone praises him like he's the best thing ever. When he's singing I'm thinking, "is there something wrong with the sound on TV? are my ears not working?" He's just garbage.

And once again, LaToya is overpraised for a mediocre performance.  :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on March 31, 2004, 01:29:41 pm
what was last night? the theme and what did people do - and how did they do?
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on March 31, 2004, 01:51:27 pm
motown
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on March 31, 2004, 02:29:21 pm
i just love george huff. i agree with whomever said that he was the man to beat, 'tis the truth.

and i hate to say it, but John Stevens really did do awful. i felt so bad for him! but he's still young, he's got lots of chances other places. I mean, how many of the top 12 people get recording deals? practically all of them.
Title: American Idol
Post by: snapple936 on March 31, 2004, 08:21:23 pm
ATTENTION AMERICA-
this is a public service announcement from a certain kelley ann

WHAT WERE YOU THINKING VOTING AMY OFF TONIGHT!?!?!??!?!


thank you, that is all.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on March 31, 2004, 09:04:35 pm
Quote from: "snapple936"
ATTENTION AMERICA-
this is a public service announcement from a certain kelley ann

WHAT WERE YOU THINKING VOTING AMY OFF TONIGHT!?!?!??!?!


thank you, that is all.

I totally agree. JPL must have legions of geekboy fans calling in. America must be tone deaf.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on March 31, 2004, 10:13:34 pm
ok, John had one bad night. that does not mean he sucks and that us fans should stop watching  :roll:
but he did choose a great song, maybe not right for him, but that's one of my favorite songs ever!

and yeah, it shows america voted wrong to get rid of Amy, she rocked!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 01, 2004, 04:31:55 am
aweful......just plain aweful......amy and la toya had no reason being in the bottom 3....let alone amy getting the boot.........
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 01, 2004, 05:31:29 am
Quote from: "Holly"
ok, John had one bad night. that does not mean he sucks and that us fans should stop watching  :roll:
Gee Holly, no one said that you should stop watching, I know this is the pot calling the kettle black, but stop being such a drama queen.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 01, 2004, 12:16:19 pm
Oh my God. I am so pissed Amy was kicked off. Allow me to rant...

Okay, so my three favorites are Amy, Jennifer, and George. The three worst in my opinion are Diana, John Peter Lewis, and Jasmine.

Diana - I'm just not crazy about her. Don't get all the hype about her. Overhype in my opinion. There are definately better girls out there. Amy and Jennifer, say. I haven't seen enough of her performances to appreciate her. I always miss hers.

John Peter Lewis - Whoever thought he had a good voice should be given a reality check. He cannot hit the big notes, he's just handsome, and he's got a ton of teenage girls voting for him multiple times on their cell phones. I dunno, I thought Leah Labelle was even better than him. *shudders*

Jasmine - She sang one song well? So? She is not that good, she had back up singers helping her a lot which should not be allowed. She was off-key and is very overrated, but she's got the whole of Hawaii on her back. Personally, I think Camile is the better Hawaiian out of the two. Yes, Camile.

Other people :

John Stevens - He's good, but not for the kind of show he's on. He could not sing the kind of music he will be given if he does get a record deal. He will not win, I guarantee, but he might get far. The fact that he got more votes than La Toya blows me away. Once he is out, he will get a record deal from the kind of music he sings, and he will succeed in that genre, but pop music is not for him. KING OF THE HILL ROCKED!

La Toya London - Very talented. Not my favorite, but I can't see how the hell she was in the bottom three. It should've been the three people I had listed that I didn't like from the Top 10. Or at least last night should've been JPL, Jasmine, and John Stevens (John's performance of My Girl was horrid).

Fantasia Barrino - I like her music taste, but she is very overrated. Her voice kinda bugs me, and I was not crazy about her Signed, Sealed, Delivered rendition. I love that song soo much and her performance was just okay to me.

Jennifer Hudson - She has an amazing voice, but not enough fans. She lives in the shadow of the other two black people : La Toya and Fantasia, who for some reason get more fans than her. Possibly because the judges like those two better than her. Somehow.

Amy Adams - OH MY FREAKING GOD. How was she voted off? That's all for her.

George Huff - Gotta love good old George. He is so awesome! Such energy. Some people said he was gay, but I don't care about that. If he is, it isn't gay like Clay. It isn't annoying. Not that I am a homophobe. I am so for gay marriages. Anywho, plain and simple, George Huff rocks.

Camile Velasco - She has potential written all over her. She gets nervous when she performs, and if she was a bit relaxed, she would be so good! I would like to see what she could do in the studio. She'd be good there.

Here are my order of what was the Top 10, favorite to least favorite :

Amy Adams
George Huff
Jennifer Hudson
La Toya London
Camile Velasco
John Stevens
Fantasia Barrino
Jasmine Trias
Diana DeGarmo
John Peter Lewis

I think that the final five will be Jasmine, John Peter, George, Fantasia, and Diana. Although that's not what I want, if you can't tell by my favorites.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 01, 2004, 12:25:33 pm
And if you dont' like Camile, she's hot.

(http://idolonfox.com/contestants/camile_velasco/images/galpic_07.jpg)
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 01, 2004, 12:32:58 pm
Well Joey, so what if she's pretty? It's not a beauty competition.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 01, 2004, 12:41:47 pm
I know, but she also has a good voice. Read the post above.
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 01, 2004, 12:53:09 pm
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
I know, but she also has a good voice. Read the post above.
I don't like Camile's voice, she has never impressed me with anything she has done on the show.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on April 01, 2004, 01:39:40 pm
You guys, be glad you don't watch the french version of AI, it suck so baaaaaad!  :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 01, 2004, 03:15:19 pm
LOL GC. I am very impressed with the performance that is on the site, I forget what it's called. She is better than Jasmine, in my opinion. Hey, but opinions will always be different.
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on April 01, 2004, 03:18:52 pm
who got kicked?
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 01, 2004, 05:11:07 pm
Quote from: "divasteph"
who got kicked?


Amy    :cuss:
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 01, 2004, 11:39:29 pm
I missed this week's AI... can someone please update me and what happened with John ( I heard he was almost crying?)?
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 02, 2004, 04:24:11 am
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I missed this week's AI... can someone please update me and what happened with John ( I heard he was almost crying?)?


yeah he did cause he knew he should have gotten kicked off.........
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 02, 2004, 10:44:23 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I missed this week's AI... can someone please update me and what happened with John ( I heard he was almost crying?)?


yeah he did cause he knew he should have gotten kicked off.........


that was a very insightful update :) thanks
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 02, 2004, 10:52:02 am
Quote from: "keith"
Quote from: "Holly"
ok, John had one bad night. that does not mean he sucks and that us fans should stop watching  :roll:
Gee Holly, no one said that you should stop watching, I know this is the pot calling the kettle black, but stop being such a drama queen.


Quote from: "Gina"
I'd stop watching the show... haha and he sucked tonite. sorry guys.  :?


ummm... keith, read the comments before you post hun.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 02, 2004, 12:07:40 pm
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
I missed this week's AI... can someone please update me and what happened with John ( I heard he was almost crying?)?


yeah he did cause he knew he should have gotten kicked off.........


that was a very insightful update :) thanks




any time....   :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 06, 2004, 04:09:43 am
anyone know what they're singing tonight?
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 06, 2004, 04:13:46 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
anyone know what they're singing tonight?


 
 NINE SINGERS REMAIN. WHO WILL BE THE IDOL?  
 
 
TONIGHT - THE MUSIC OF SIR ELTON JOHN!

A new theme each week. A new song to learn. A new audience to perform in front of. Competing on American Idol doesn't get any easier, but with each passing week it gets more important. Tonight's all right for fightin' with the song book of SIR ELTON JOHN. Who will deliver a knockout performance this week? Who will struggle? And who will connect with the fans and get their votes? Find out TONIGHT at 8/7c on FOX!

Then come back tomorrow at 8/7c for a special one-hour live results show when nine will become eight and the challenge becomes even greater for the contestants!

 Special Guest Tamyra Gray will perform “Raindrops Will Fall,” a stunning ballad from her upcoming solo debut tomorrow night! Also, don't miss her appearance on the series “Tru Calling” on April 15 @ 8/7c on FOX.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 06, 2004, 06:32:45 am
interesting...
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 06, 2004, 12:06:38 pm
Quote from: "BWilli"
interesting...
Who cares about the competition?!

TAMYRA!!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 06, 2004, 06:01:53 pm
JENNIFER HUDSON ROCKS YOUR SOCKS
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 06, 2004, 06:24:30 pm
That's funny because Fantashia rocked mine...I mean I know she was screechy....but did you hear her with just her and the piano omg!! AMAZING.
Title: American Idol
Post by: snapple936 on April 06, 2004, 07:31:12 pm
ELTON JOHN ELTON JOHN ELTON JOHN

oh and the american idol contestants

BUT MOSTLY ELTON JOHN

rocked my socks


(and i thought camille was good tonight!)

(and i wish jpl would go away!!!)

thank you.

kelley
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on April 07, 2004, 03:49:17 am
Poor John Stevens.....just wasn't with it tonight :-/ I feel bad because I love his voice, he just didn't do well at all. I think Simon was being a little harsh on Camille, I don't think it was her worse performance, but i don't think it was her best.

george was amazing once again, and so was fantasia!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 07, 2004, 05:03:52 am
John Stevens = sucked

Camille = sucked

Fantasia = okay

JPL = average

Diana = good as usual

Jen Hudson = better than normal

La Toya = very good as always

Jasmine = the best she's ever sang

George Huff = probably winning this competition

I felt bad that Jasmie got criticized so much by them.....she sang great last night..........

Camille is probably going home, but I'm finding it hard to see who else will be in the bottom three.....I think John Steven should be, but all those friggen teenage girls keep voting for him....however, it may have gotten to him this week.....

Bottom 3 are:  Camille, John and.....Diana  w/ Camille going home (however I'd rather see John Stevens outta here)

I'd be very surprised to see La Toya in the bottom 3 again.......
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 07, 2004, 05:45:21 am
Brian, those are the bottom three that YOU want?

I want : John Peter, John, and Jasmine in the bottom 3. I can't stand either of those 3.

I think that then bottom 3 will be : Jennifer, Camile, and Diana.

I want John Stevens gone, but I think Camile WILL go. I dunno.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 07, 2004, 06:09:50 am
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
Brian, those are the bottom three that YOU want?


No.....thats who I think will be in the bottom three....


I definately  want John Stevens in there, and I could do without Jen Hudson, but I think she was too good last night and may get a lot of votes...

I think Jasmine is great.....JPL I think is just okay, but he's got a big fan base so far....

Like I said....I think G. Huff is going to win it all
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 08, 2004, 03:30:01 am
well.....i had two out of three in the bottom, and i was right on who went home, but John Stevens still does not belong there
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 08, 2004, 07:24:17 am
I had two of the bottom three right, and the boot right.

Just like Brian, lol.

Camile was better than John Stevens. Grrrr.
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 10, 2004, 06:03:30 am
This week they are singing songs from the movies.

Should be interesting...


I LOVE Fantasia
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 10, 2004, 11:20:58 am
Yep, TV Guide said something like, "The 7 remaining finalists and John Stevens perform Movie hits Tuesday at 8:00...." lol
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on April 10, 2004, 02:07:01 pm
who was booted?
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 10, 2004, 06:00:43 pm
Camille got kicked off
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 12, 2004, 05:42:20 am
Answer me this..........

WHY IN THE HELL IS QUENTIN TARANTINO THE GUEST JUDGE THIS WEEK?

I know he deals with films, but what makes him a judge for a music competition?
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 12, 2004, 05:54:27 am
This says it all...
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4649112
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 14, 2004, 11:20:22 pm
Fantasia blew me away tonight with "Summertime"! Wow!! she did so incredible i like got chills! definitely the best performance of the season so far because not only did she sing it perfectly... but she acted out the emotion in it!
LaToya's voice was of Whitney Houston quality tonight I think! She killed that song (in a good way!). And I love "Somewhere"!!
John did great tonight! Great song choice!!
And I loved Jasmine as well!!

Everyone else did alright... but those are the 4 that were my fave performances hands down!
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 15, 2004, 12:31:42 am
My fave tonight was Jennifer...   but I'm still all about that red-head.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 15, 2004, 03:24:25 am
La Toya was the best of the night....

George is still the man

JPL was much better tonight (even though he missed a line)

John Stevens still bores the hell outta me, but he chose the right song for him...

Jen Hudson was very good, but still scares me

Jasmine was good again as well.....

Fantasia was pretty amazing....very very good

Diana.....go bye bye

my guess for the bottom three are:  Diana, Jasmine, and......Jen..with Diana going home....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on April 15, 2004, 07:41:16 am
fantasia and latoya blew it up last night!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 15, 2004, 08:27:22 am
Quote from: "Alecs"
fantasia and latoya blew it up last night!


hey...what ever you're smokin'.....can i get some???
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 15, 2004, 04:31:28 pm
WOW!!!


Finally Stevens is in the bottom three....i only had one right (Diana)....and JPL is there for the first time.....

and whats even more surprising is the Diana was sent back to the couch first......WOW!

and JPL goes home.....

WHY CAN'T WE JUST GET RID OF THIS BORING KID?!?!?!?!?!?!
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 15, 2004, 04:40:24 pm
they had the bottom 3 right!!

now if the other 2 can get gone in the next 2 weeks...
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 15, 2004, 04:51:26 pm
I couldn't agree more.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 15, 2004, 10:27:05 pm
i was so scared that John Stevens might go! but thankfully it was JPL!
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 15, 2004, 11:16:05 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
i was so scared that John Stevens might go! but thankfully it was JPL!


OHHHKAY!!?!?!


I was so freaked out at work! I was feeling bad because I forgot to vote last night! I am so voting next week... I love that kid. Jasmine and Diana must go next....
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 16, 2004, 05:15:48 am
Let the kid go! lol he will be famous anyway...just let him go....or tell him to get a mystic tan....it's just creepy.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 16, 2004, 07:35:57 am
Hahaha, joey i love you
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 16, 2004, 08:59:49 am
yeah nicole!! we must keep our boy on the show! next week we must have one of our voting competitions! haha.  :D  :wink:

Quote from: "LimeTwister"
Let the kid go! lol he will be famous anyway...just let him go....or tell him to get a mystic tan....it's just creepy.


no! we will not let him leave AI!   :evil:
and i dont think being tan would work with his features if you ask me, but yeah, he is definitely pale! but i got a mystic tan!  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 16, 2004, 09:18:06 am
True that a tan wouldn't work with his features haha... it'd look pretty funny.  

But... I'm sorry Holls- I do think he should go atleast in the next 2 weeks.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 16, 2004, 09:24:29 am
Quote from: "Gina"
True that a tan wouldn't work with his features haha... it'd look pretty funny.  

But... I'm sorry Holls- I do think he should go atleast in the next 2 weeks.


why? so we could loose the variety and then have a bunch of people who all sound alike! he's the only one who sticks out as being special!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 16, 2004, 09:28:36 am
It's not that I think he's a bad singer, I just honestly don't think he should be an American Idol, and I couldn't see him selling that many albums honestly.  I think Diana should go first, then him... I mean its an accomplishment to make it into the top 10, all the people that like him will continue to support him, but I don't think he could win it all anyway.  My personal opinion.  I like him more than I liked JPL though.. that's for sure.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 16, 2004, 10:02:36 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "Gina"
True that a tan wouldn't work with his features haha... it'd look pretty funny.  

But... I'm sorry Holls- I do think he should go atleast in the next 2 weeks.


why? so we could loose the variety and then have a bunch of people who all sound alike! he's the only one who sticks out as being special!


yea, but there are unique voices that are AWESOME (Fantashia).  I don't really enjoy that type of music he does...and it just begins to sound the same...and then when he tried to do something different (laaaaa lalalalaaaaaaa with Elton John's song) it just came out all wrong!

He is like a blast from the past, but needs to go work in like Vegas or something.  American Idol? no.
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 16, 2004, 11:05:41 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
yeah nicole!! we must keep our boy on the show! next week we must have one of our voting competitions! haha.  :D  :wink:



you're on!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 17, 2004, 07:55:36 am
I only got 15 votes in for Jennifer before I got kicked off the phone. :(

Fantasia was REALLY good on Wednesday. I am listening to it right now. She was my 2nd favorite of the night (Jennifer was 1st, of course). La Toya was also good. George doesn't handle slow songs really well.... Diana was BAD. JPL and JS sucked as usual and Jasmine can't sing.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 17, 2004, 10:14:48 am
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
Quote from: "Holly"
yeah nicole!! we must keep our boy on the show! next week we must have one of our voting competitions! haha.  :D  :wink:



you're on!


*gets phone ready*

John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 17, 2004, 03:36:58 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
Quote from: "Holly"
yeah nicole!! we must keep our boy on the show! next week we must have one of our voting competitions! haha.  :D  :wink:



you're on!


*gets phone ready*

John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!!

How the hell do you two like him?
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 17, 2004, 04:46:56 pm
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "loveplasticlove"
Quote from: "Holly"
yeah nicole!! we must keep our boy on the show! next week we must have one of our voting competitions! haha.  :D  :wink:



you're on!


*gets phone ready*

John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!! John Stevens!!

How the hell do you two like him?


 :spiral:
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 17, 2004, 04:52:57 pm
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
How the hell do you two like [John Stevens]?

The thing about a show like American Idol is that there are different kinds singers--J.S. is different and in a class by himself, so of course he will have fans, no one sings like he does, he's unique. Maybe thats why.

But for whatever reason, it's their personal preference...they can like who they want.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 17, 2004, 10:42:14 pm
Quote from: "keith"
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
How the hell do you two like [John Stevens]?

The thing about a show like American Idol is that there are different kinds singers--J.S. is different and in a class by himself, so of course he will have fans, no one sings like he does, he's unique. Maybe thats why.

But for whatever reason, it's their personal preference...they can like who they want.


yeah... Joey, do you think everyone likes the same stuff you do? Guess what, people have different preferences, what a concept! And obviously a lot of people have this same preference if he's stuck around this long! I could never be so obsessed with a tennis player, but do I think it's weird that you are? No, it's your preference!

*applauds keith*
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 18, 2004, 06:54:31 am
1) I understand that people have different preferences and differences, and that people think that some singers are good, and other's won't.

2) I am sorry.

3) I wouldn't call myself obsessed with Henrieta Nagyova.  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on April 19, 2004, 09:06:36 pm
I cant believe you guys got rid of Camille and Amy Adams  :cry:  they were so great.
Camille was my favorite, she didnt have the greatest voice but she seemed nice.
Im not sure who i want to win now.
Also JPL shouldnt of gone last week, Jon Stevens would of been better to go.
Just my opinion.
 :D Goooooooo Diana (shes my fav now)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 20, 2004, 02:27:57 pm
my choices for the next 2 to go are Diana and Jennifer.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 20, 2004, 04:56:24 pm
John Stevens and Diana should go next.... :?  Just my personal opinion.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on April 20, 2004, 05:13:30 pm
I agree with Gina. Jasmine too if she's still there.
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 20, 2004, 05:21:26 pm
the talent just doesnt seem as good this year. Amy def. should still be in...Jon needs to go, JPL couldnt sing or dance either.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 20, 2004, 05:24:00 pm
Diana - the best she's ever sang

George - he's sang better, but he still the man

Jen - still scares me with those facial expressions, but not bad

Fantasia - good as usual

La Toya - great as usual

Jasmie - better than usual

John Stevens - sucked as usual

it's rough to pick the bottom three, but my guesses are John, Jasmine, Diana, w/ John finally getting the boot
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 20, 2004, 05:30:10 pm
What did JOhn sing tonight?
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 20, 2004, 10:38:30 pm
mandy


and I vote like 40 times... hah I might get some more in but I'm kind of tired. :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 21, 2004, 05:06:39 pm
you have god to be kidding me! That was the most insane bottom 3 I have EVVVVER seen!  And Jennifer sure as hell did NOT deserve to go.  I'm honestly in shock right now.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on April 21, 2004, 05:12:14 pm
My friend told me that and I was seriously hoping she was messing with me. That is just ridiculous.

I asked what the judges thought and she said they are in shock.

Wow, crazy!!  :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 21, 2004, 05:16:56 pm
Shock is not even the word to describe it.



I N S A N E




I'm so mad right now...over a silly tv show. But its unbelieveable- the best 3 at the bottom 3! ok, someone please explain this? John Stevens needs to go. He knows it too, because everyweek the cameras focus on his shocked look that he didnt lose.


ah wow. this season is whacked.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 21, 2004, 05:21:08 pm
Yeah, so I decided that if next week Fantasia or LaToya goes... I'm done watching it.  People are RIDICULOUS! Now come on, clean out yer f'in ears.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on April 21, 2004, 05:21:11 pm
haha, that made me laugh, thanks.

*edit* Gina posted before I could but yours made me laugh too.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 21, 2004, 05:22:36 pm
And yes I know it's sad that I get so worked up over a show...haha
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 21, 2004, 05:24:13 pm
seriously gina, its not even worth my time anymore if this show is gonna go on by being a popularity contest. its clear on who the best and the worst *cough John Stevens* are
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on April 21, 2004, 06:02:38 pm
Has America gone crazy!??!?!?! what the hell!??!?!

I love John Stevens, but he does need to go. He's not performing nearly half as well as anyone else in there, much less Jennifer Hudson.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 21, 2004, 06:07:33 pm
*clears throat*






















THIS SHOW IS FREEKING RIGGED! AS A MEMBER OF CLUB HUD AND A JENNIFER SUPPORTER IN GENERAL I AM BOYCOTTING THIS SHOW. It was obvious how they set it up that this show is a sham. They don't do groups with 7 people left, and they put the best 3 in the bottom 3 to get better ratingd, to get more attention, and honestly, it will only lose them viewers by getting rid of Jen. She was amazing, and is going to be a great artist. I have to go, bye!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 21, 2004, 06:18:15 pm
okay....i agree that something is definately wrong here....

i never liked jen hudson, i've always said she scares me, and to be honest, i'm not too surprised that she got the boot...BUT....my dad said he got through on Hudson's line 200 times...well if someone can get through that easily, than not a lot of people are voting....so thats one thing

i am however surprised at how the whole bottom 3 looked....very very strange.....

if however it was rigged...i think they shoulda handled it better, by atleast having someone who really sucks (and at this point the only one left who really sucks it John Steven) in the bottom three....then have it come down to the really good one and really bad one...and then boot the good one off.....that's how I would produce the show ONLY IF I WANTED RATINGS though.....not have 3 of the best in the bottom three...but anyway....

whats done is done....i'm still routin' for George...
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 21, 2004, 06:18:21 pm
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
THIS SHOW IS FREEKING RIGGED!
Alot of us have known this since the Tamyra screw job in season one.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 21, 2004, 06:28:55 pm
Quote from: "keith"
Quote from: "Nagyovafan"
THIS SHOW IS FREEKING RIGGED!
Alot of us have known this since the Tamyra screw job in season one.


So true.
Title: American Idol
Post by: loveplasticlove on April 21, 2004, 11:59:53 pm
I was told on the phone before the show started... boy was I delighted :)  Don't worry people... John Stevens will be out soon enough.  I love him, but I know he won't win... but I'll support him til it happens.  My 2nd choice was Jen Hudson.  I am really shocked that she is gone.  She did an amazing job on the movie night.  And I liked her cause she was a cute heavy girl and she had lost so much weight... we need more people who look normal.  I can not stand Latoya... she is so full of herself.  I loved her face when she saw that she was the bottom 3. :)  I think it should be either her or Jasmine with Diana trailing not too far behind.
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on April 22, 2004, 09:27:18 am
On "The View" today I had to laugh. I knew they would talk about AI, and well Star said she didn't want to talk bad about anyone but that they show is a popularity contest. So here's what cracked me up. She said, "There is no way that little child with the red hair is better than Jennifer Hudson."

Then Elizabeth was saying that she didn't vote and that people are thinking that those ladies are so good that people don't really feel that they need to vote or what not and well I guess they do.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 22, 2004, 09:30:45 am
I was shocked at the bottom 3 too!! I was like the bottom 3 is definitely group B! I was glad JS wasnt in the bottom... but was mad that fantasia and latoya were! I love those two!! i think fantasia is tied for my favorite now! Jennifer is talented, but seemed the most cocky... and thats something i hate, so i havent liked her since the beginning, i wasnt upset she got kicked off at all!
poor george! i think they scared the hell outta him last night... being left on the couch alone and then not knowing which group to go with! he was like shaking! there's something adorable about him! haha

my faves, in order are now

1. John
2. Fantasia
3. La Toya
4. Jasmine
5. George
6. Diana
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on April 22, 2004, 09:46:17 am
1. Diana
2. Jasmine
3. Fantasia
4. John
5. George
6. La Toya
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on April 22, 2004, 11:13:19 am
now Steph would it be Diana cause she's from GA? haha.


It's also funny cause on "On-Air with Ryan Seacrest" he has a panel of past AI people and all 3 said that John was going home. I can't wait to watch it today cause he is all about "Inside Idol" and Jennifer with be on. She is also going to do a duet with Barry Manilow who is a guest today.

Yes, I am an "On-Air" WHORE!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 22, 2004, 02:08:04 pm
lmao at Let being the On Air whore!  :lol:  :wink:

I really want to watch it today but I'm going to be at work! you'll have to let me know how it is! or maybe i can get my vcr to work and tape it
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 22, 2004, 05:59:58 pm
Favs...

1. George
2. La Toya
3. Diana
4. Jasmine
5. Fantasia
6. John S.
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on April 22, 2004, 11:25:30 pm
Ok American Idol makes me very, very, extremly, so cross!
JEN HUDSON?
Whats going on here?
Not only does it make me cross but it also confuses me, I know Im Australian blah blah and what gives me the right to say my opinion on this show but wow you guys just keep on voting off such talented people.
I really hope these guys get a second chance because they seem so nice and talented. I would love to meet them.
I still dont like Jon Stevens but he seems like a down to earth young guy.
Here are my favorite now:

1.Diana
2.George
3.Jasmine
 :wink:

Take care guys and I dont know, maybe make a petition to get some of these talented folk back lol.
Title: American Idol
Post by: TSE on April 23, 2004, 02:29:33 am
Quote from: "The Associated Press
April  23, 2004"
. . .A storm that caused a power outage in the Midwest may have been a factor in Hudson’s ouster, TV entertainment newsmagazine “Extra” said Thursday.

More than 15,000 people in Hudson’s hometown of Chicago were unable to watch the show or dial in Tuesday night, when the vote turned out to be the closest in the show’s three-year history, “Extra” said . . .


*link* (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4809353/)

I still don't watch. . .there are baseball games on, people!  Now tell me that this silly show is more important than BASEBALL!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 23, 2004, 03:54:23 am
Quote from: "TSE"
Quote from: "The Associated Press
April  23, 2004"
. . .A storm that caused a power outage in the Midwest may have been a factor in Hudson’s ouster, TV entertainment newsmagazine “Extra” said Thursday.

More than 15,000 people in Hudson’s hometown of Chicago were unable to watch the show or dial in Tuesday night, when the vote turned out to be the closest in the show’s three-year history, “Extra” said . . .


*link* (http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/4809353/)

I still don't watch. . .there are baseball games on, people!  Now tell me that this silly show is more important than BASEBALL!


i heard bout that power outage thing.....

oh...and when your b-ball team is the Mets, as mine is, yes, I'd rather watch american idol than watch the Mets get slaughtered as usual.... :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 23, 2004, 11:53:55 am
Honestly, who cares about Jennifer Hudson getting the boot? It's not like she was going to win.

It's going to come down to Fantasia and LaToya in the end, it has to, they are the only two left with actual talent.

Next Week:
Gloria Estefan!

WHO WILL BECOME THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL?

In the round of seven, Jennifer wasn't able to handle the music of Barry Manilow. Now that we're in the round of six, who will be able to handle the music of Gloria Estefan? The rhythm is gonna get American Idol this week as the contestant take on Ms. Estefan's upbeat numbers.

Who will make the Miami Sound Machine proud? And who buckle in the face of increasing pressure? Find out during another round of live performance this Tuesday at 8/7c on FOX!

Then come back Wednesday at 8:30/7:30 for the live results. Only five can move on, so another one's going home!
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on April 23, 2004, 12:03:17 pm
Yeah, taht power outage thing isn't really fair...
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 26, 2004, 09:31:12 am
Quote from: "keith"
It's going to come down to Fantasia and LaToya in the end, it has to, they are the only two left with actual talent.


I have to add George into that category....sure....last week he didn't do well, but the guy has a lot of talent....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on April 26, 2004, 01:45:36 pm
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "keith"
It's going to come down to Fantasia and LaToya in the end, it has to, they are the only two left with actual talent.


I have to add George into that category....sure....last week he didn't do well, but the guy has a lot of talent....


yeah I agree but I still think Latoya has it in the bag.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 26, 2004, 05:47:08 pm
Quote from: "Alecs"
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "keith"
It's going to come down to Fantasia and LaToya in the end, it has to, they are the only two left with actual talent.


I have to add George into that category....sure....last week he didn't do well, but the guy has a lot of talent....


yeah I agree but I still think Latoya has it in the bag.


honestly, I think it's too hard to tell.....a lot of people thought Hudson was going all the way, and she's out already....i like La Toya though and hope she sticks around....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 27, 2004, 04:45:15 pm
randy said it best when he said that john stevens vocals tonite were HORRENDOUS!... I'm sorry but he really must go.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 27, 2004, 08:26:34 pm
I think it's pretty safe to assume that a girl is going to win it this year!

for performances tonight i'd have to say La Toya and Jasmine were my 2 faves, then Fantasia, then Diana.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 28, 2004, 03:36:06 am
Quote from: "Holly"
for performances tonight i'd have to say La Toya and Jasmine were my 2 faves, then Fantasia, then Diana.


Really??

Diana was by far the best of the night, followed by La Toya and Jasmine...

1.  Diana
2.  La Toya
3.  Jasmine
4.  George
5.  Fantasia
6.  John

i don't think the the bottom three will be the way I have it, but i seriously think it's time for stevens to go home already.  That was the worst performance by a finalist I have ever seen on the show....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on April 28, 2004, 08:54:57 am
Oh I wish I could watch AI... :(
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 28, 2004, 09:13:03 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "Holly"
for performances tonight i'd have to say La Toya and Jasmine were my 2 faves, then Fantasia, then Diana.


Really??

Diana was by far the best of the night, followed by La Toya and Jasmine...


haha, it's ok... i have my opinion and you have yours!
don't get me wrong, Diana did great! but i just liked the other's a bit more!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 28, 2004, 11:10:16 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "Holly"
for performances tonight i'd have to say La Toya and Jasmine were my 2 faves, then Fantasia, then Diana.


Really??

Diana was by far the best of the night, followed by La Toya and Jasmine...


haha, it's ok... i have my opinion and you have yours!
don't get me wrong, Diana did great! but i just liked the other's a bit more!


it's all good   :D

honestly I think its all La Toya now....although I'm hoping George will do good like he did the first few weeks....
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 28, 2004, 04:59:34 pm
FUCK YEA!!!! GOOOOOOO HOOOOOOOOMEEEEEEEEEE, BAD SINGER!!!!

 :?

um, I mean how sad.
Title: American Idol
Post by: B on April 28, 2004, 05:04:01 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
FUCK YEA!!!! GOOOOOOO HOOOOOOOOMEEEEEEEEEE, BAD SINGER!!!!

 :?

um, I mean how sad.


*Waits for people to begin crying and squealing and saying they will never watch American Idol again because the readhead dude is gone* LOL  :twisted:

He is the only person everyone is talking about and I'm all  :?: because I don't watch, lol.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on April 28, 2004, 05:07:59 pm
HAHA... I'm so happy, I mean- not trying to be mean, but he really deserved to go.  

GO FANTASIA! (even tho last night she wasn't at her best shes still my FAV)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on April 28, 2004, 06:08:49 pm
Three words : Good fucking riddance. I said it.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 28, 2004, 06:36:25 pm
WELL IT'S ABOUT FRIGGEN TIME


he lasted way too long.....

Glad to see George is still in it....def. a close call.....however I honestly think La Toya will (and should) win it all...(although if Diana keeps up the way she did this week...it's a possibility that she may pull out the win)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on April 28, 2004, 09:37:02 pm
this was the most emotional episode yet! you could tell John was a popular one with the contestants. and it's not hard to see why! He's just got such a sweet personality and the strength to put up with all the shit some assholes would throw at him! He's 16!! give him a break! geeze! He's talented at what he does... and trust me, this will not be the last you see of him!
i just dont see how anyone can be so rude and mean to someone who is one of the nicest guys ever. he's talented too! look how far he made it!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on April 29, 2004, 03:43:11 am
eh!  I think he made it this far because of popularity....not talent....

almost like Josh Gracin from last season (who is a million times better than Stevens) but lasted a lot longer than he should have....

i'll give Stevens this....he can sing like Sinatra, and you're right, we'll prolly see his CD out eventually.....but he can only sing one type of music...he doesn't have much range at all.....not like the rest of the contestants on the show.....

he had one good night, because he picked a song in the genre that he only knows how to sing ( i think that was the movie night, not sure)....but he couldn't switch it up when trying to sing Elton John or Gloria Estefan's songs.....

sure....i'll admit, it's a little sad to see someone get the boot from the show, but i'm glad he's out, the other contestants are a lot better....

Like I said, I'd love to see George do good like the first few weeks, but I think it's going to be either La Toya or Diana(if she can keep up the good work...)
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on April 29, 2004, 11:31:34 am
Holly, you're right. I shouldn't be so mean, but it's not like I hate him as a person...just that he couldn't sing the stuff that was put there for him.  I think that is partly American Idol's fault (WHO can sing all of that crap?), but at the same time we don't want it repetitive to the point that it is dreary.  I think age does have something to do with it.  I think throughout his career he will get to learn what he needs, and THEN he will be better.  

I still think he should have gone home before others.  That's not his fault but it still pisses some off.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on April 29, 2004, 11:45:08 am
it's sad to see him go - but you can't deny that his performances were getting worse as the show went on. I still love him though!
Title: American Idol
Post by: keith on April 29, 2004, 01:40:39 pm
This was hilarious...

(http://img2.photobucket.com/albums/v11/keithrj997/killjohn.jpg)
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 02, 2004, 06:21:46 pm
Im starting to like Jasmine more than Diana now.
I loved Simon's comment to Fantasia about her sounding like a cartoon character LOL.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 02, 2004, 09:16:00 pm
Quote from: "aleera84"
Im starting to like Jasmine more than Diana now.
I loved Simon's comment to Fantasia about her sounding like a cartoon character LOL.


i thought that was mean! i <3 Fantasia! she's one of those performers that just makes me happy when I see them perform! she exudes cheerfulness and she's very unique and talented!
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 02, 2004, 11:26:40 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "aleera84"
Im starting to like Jasmine more than Diana now.
I loved Simon's comment to Fantasia about her sounding like a cartoon character LOL.


i thought that was mean! i <3 Fantasia! she's one of those performers that just makes me happy when I see them perform! she exudes cheerfulness and she's very unique and talented!

Perhaps but hey we all have our own opinions Holls, I think she is a very lively and talented person but she just doesnt do it for me.
I really like American Idol, its much better than Australian Idol for some reason.
I guess its because I dont have to vote every week, argh you guys have it so good because we had to pay to vote for our Idol favorites.
Its good that she makes you feel happy though, there was this one Idol fav of mine over here named Cosima who made me happy but she had to pull out because her throat got sore and she became really sick.
(shes in my avatar- Michelle Branch, Hilary Duff and Cosima)
Lots of <3 Holly and thank you for writing in my LJ, I miss you aswell.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jay_Oh on May 03, 2004, 05:10:50 pm
Meh, who cares about American idol, New Zealand Idols much better! :P Luke was my favourite one in New Zealand idol and he just left :( see what he sounds like here... http://flipside.nzoom.com/flipside_detail/1,2359,269597-212-223,00.html

or here...

http://www.nzidol.com/top10_luke.html
Title: American Idol
Post by: Dancernl on May 04, 2004, 05:16:30 pm
my affection for George is waning and building for Diana.  She was fantastic tonight, probably the best.  LaToya was great as usual.  I like Fantasia but I don't think she was that spectacular.  Should be interesting from now on though.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 04, 2004, 05:56:49 pm
I have to disagree on the Diana thing, I honestly didn't think she was all that wonderful tonight, I don't necessarily think she'll go, I kinda think Jaz will go, even though I do like her.  I thought La Toya was really good- I actually enjoyed her tonight.  Fantasia's still my favorite, simply because she has a unique voice and amazing personality... I thought she did really well tonight, maybe not her best but- still real good.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 04, 2004, 08:08:44 pm
Simon said it best when he said Fantasia and LaToya were in a league of their own! They both stand so high above the others... and I think it'll be a showdown between them at the end! And they are the only 2 who have been consistantly good! Neither of them has ever had a bad night!

my fave peformances of tonight:
1. LaToya
2. Fantasia
3. Diana
4. George
5. Jasmine

Fantasia is my favorite... and I think Jasmine will go home tomorrow. She's good! She just didnt compare to the others tonight!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 05, 2004, 03:32:19 am
I don't think it was right for Simon and Randy to say what they said in the end, (about who'd be in the final two).  They have their choices, but they should keep it to themselves for the time being.  I think it made the other contestants feel like crap.

All in all, not such a bad show.

1.  La Toya
2.  Diana
3.  Fantasia
4.  Jasmine
5.  George (damn, he was at the top of my list when the show started few months back)

La Toya should win it all I think.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 05, 2004, 03:51:43 am
bleh, i'm definitely rooting for Jasmine to go home. She just didn't sound that good last night, really flat and off pitch.

I LOVED Fantasia's songs, they were so goood!

George was ok, he's staying kind of static though so i haven't really seen him do anything different.

I thought Diana was good performance wise - she always is. As for the vocals, i'd say she was better than Jasmine but no George.

Latoya was really good as well! I think it's going to be a tough competiton between her and (as Simon would say it) Fahnayzseeeuh.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 05, 2004, 06:42:50 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
I don't think it was right for Simon and Randy to say what they said in the end, (about who'd be in the final two).  They have their choices, but they should keep it to themselves for the time being.  I think it made the other contestants feel like crap.


but come on... that wasnt even in the top 1000 of the meanest things they have said. It wasn't mean and I think the other contestants know it anyways... they've got to be watching the show, looking at LaToya's and Fantasias performances and know they're always good and never get a bad comment on their performance.
and this job isnt about the judges keeping things to themselves, incase you havent noticed. haha
but sometimes Simon does go overboard... like comparing Amy to Jay Leno, John to that comedian, and Fantasia to a cartoon character. those comments are mean and do no good whatsoever
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 05, 2004, 08:54:11 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "BWilli"
I don't think it was right for Simon and Randy to say what they said in the end, (about who'd be in the final two).  They have their choices, but they should keep it to themselves for the time being.  I think it made the other contestants feel like crap.


but come on... that wasnt even in the top 1000 of the meanest things they have said. It wasn't mean and I think the other contestants know it anyways... they've got to be watching the show, looking at LaToya's and Fantasias performances and know they're always good and never get a bad comment on their performance.
and this job isnt about the judges keeping things to themselves, incase you havent noticed. haha
but sometimes Simon does go overboard... like comparing Amy to Jay Leno, John to that comedian, and Fantasia to a cartoon character. those comments are mean and do no good whatsoever



yeah.....but still.....it doesn't help their confidence at all....granted, they are most likely right....it'll come down to La Toya and Fantasia (maybe even La Toya and Diana).....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 05, 2004, 11:46:00 am
I really hope it doesn't come down to La Toya and Diana... blah
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 05, 2004, 05:04:57 pm
poor George, I honestly thought Jasmine was gonna go, but George woulda gone soon anyway, he wouldn't have been final 2
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 05, 2004, 05:36:14 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
poor George, I honestly thought Jasmine was gonna go, but George woulda gone soon anyway, he wouldn't have been final 2


Ditto.

i felt so bad! I heart george huff! i would have liked to have seen him go at least one more week
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 05, 2004, 05:45:26 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Gina"
poor George, I honestly thought Jasmine was gonna go, but George woulda gone soon anyway, he wouldn't have been final 2


Ditto.

i felt so bad! I heart george huff! i would have liked to have seen him go at least one more week


I liked him too, one more week woulda been nice... Jasmine will go next week (even though I do like her... she deserves to go)
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 05, 2004, 06:08:35 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Gina"
poor George, I honestly thought Jasmine was gonna go, but George woulda gone soon anyway, he wouldn't have been final 2


Ditto.

i felt so bad! I heart george huff! i would have liked to have seen him go at least one more week


I liked him too, one more week woulda been nice... Jasmine will go next week (even though I do like her... she deserves to go)


I agree (again lol). I think it will be Jasmine voted off next, then Diana, and then LaToya, and Fantasia will get it. I like all of them though, and i agree with what Paula said, that none of them will have any trouble getting a recording contract
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 05, 2004, 06:10:50 pm
yay, that makes me happy to hear you say that you think Fantasia will win  :D  Me and Joey want her to!
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 05, 2004, 06:17:26 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
yay, that makes me happy to hear you say that you think Fantasia will win  :D  Me and Joey want her to!


after her performance yesterday i decided that's who i wanted to win - it was amazing! it really showed her range -from r&b to big band.....so hopefully she'll get it!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 05, 2004, 09:10:32 pm
I <3 George Huff! He's so adorable and smiley and very talented! I'll miss him.... but I think it was time for him to go.

now it's all about girl power! haha

Fantasia is my favorite too! I have never seen anyone put as much emotion into her performances as she does!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 06, 2004, 03:47:20 am
Sad to see George go....but someone had to.....I think most people knew that a female was going to win this year.....

I still think it's going to be La Toya.....she only gets better as the competition moves on....
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on May 11, 2004, 02:18:39 pm
This season is the worst ever.

We are at the point of that there are 4 ladies left and the 4 arent the best there can possibly be. George lasted this long, and defiently shouldnt have. Im just saying that the compitition should be good enough that there arent any bad people left. ((you all knwo waht I mean?))

I hope Diana doesnt make it past this week....same with Jasmine. They just arent good enough.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 11, 2004, 02:26:03 pm
Quote from: "1vcfan"

I hope Diana doesnt make it past this week....same with Jasmine. They just arent good enough.


I agree that they aren't good enough
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on May 11, 2004, 02:58:07 pm
omg I heard the funniest thing last night on Leno...

Wanda Sykes was on and so were Simon, Randy and Paula. Anyhow...

Jay was asking if she watched the show and she said that she was a fan. She said that she didn't understand how at the end of the show the person who gets kicked off is asked to sing. She was all, so now do a song for us so we can all remember why America voted you off, how much you suck and are going home. Something like that. It was so hilarious.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on May 11, 2004, 02:59:16 pm
Latoya all the way!!!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 11, 2004, 05:06:30 pm
Ok.....

first set of songs from best to worst...

DIANA - F'ING AMAZING
La Toya - great as always
Fantasia - what was with the sound effect....not bad i guess
Jasmine - looked like she was lip-singing (but oddly when they showed the replay it didn't)

second set from best to worst

DIANA - F'ING AMAZING AGAIN
La Toya - a whole lot better
Jasmine - WAY better than the first performance
Fantasia - worst of her performances ever

all in all

1.  DIANA
2.  LA TOYA
3.  JASMINE (her second performance bumped her up as i see it)
4.  FANTASIA

however i think Jasmine will be leaving us....
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 11, 2004, 05:12:02 pm
i thought diana was the best

then Fantasia

then Latoya

and then Jasmine.....she needs to go......i mean, she's a nice girl, but she's been consistently bad and flat in all her songs, imho
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on May 11, 2004, 07:25:35 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
i thought diana was the best

then Fantasia

then Latoya

and then Jasmine.....she needs to go......i mean, she's a nice girl, but she's been consistently bad and flat in all her songs, imho


I agree. I haven't been a Diana fan but damn she was smoking!!! I'm sure sweet, (very cute by the way) Jasmine is  gone. I don't know what tothink next week because I think they are all so f'ing good!!!! Latoya is soooooooooooooooooooo classy so she has my vote!
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on May 11, 2004, 08:16:37 pm
well I actually watched the whole show today. Poor Jasmine, I felt for her when she was crying. I guess she too knows that she didn't do too well. She just seems like she is trying too hard.

I think Diana did really well and the other two were good too. But I actually voted for Diana, haha. Why do they say the lines aren't open when they are?
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on May 11, 2004, 09:31:57 pm
Quote from: "eclv"
well I actually watched the whole show today. Poor Jasmine, I felt for her when she was crying. I guess she too knows that she didn't do too well. She just seems like she is trying too hard.

I think Diana did really well and the other two were good too. But I actually voted for Diana, haha. Why do they say the lines aren't open when they are?


I don't know but I haven't gotten through once!
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 12, 2004, 03:47:01 am
Quote from: "eclv"
well I actually watched the whole show today. Poor Jasmine, I felt for her when she was crying. I guess she too knows that she didn't do too well. She just seems like she is trying too hard.

I think Diana did really well and the other two were good too. But I actually voted for Diana, haha. Why do they say the lines aren't open when they are?


i felt bad for her when she started crying because i had just gotten done saying how bad i thought she did! but it's the truth, and at least it's building a backbone for her, you know? The music industry can be harsh.

anyways, my two votes are for Diana and Fantasia. If either of them get it I will be more than happy
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 12, 2004, 04:57:26 am
hmm.....you never know......that whole crying thing could've been strategy.....it may help her get some votes....

but Diana still ruled the night....and I still can't stand Fantasia....
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on May 12, 2004, 07:13:41 am
i hated fantasia's second song - its not even disco - it's 80's....
of course as always diana got the one vote i got through
the lines were BUSY...last night... even though i was just votin for diana...
i think latoya looks like an AI - but diana has the voice and fantasia has the personality....

hmmm - the worst thing about jasmine is she lost the flower --- that was her trademark just like ruben and his shirts - girl dont lose your trademark
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on May 12, 2004, 12:59:45 pm
1st Set
----------
1. Diana - Teh best! For the first time ever, I loved her performance.
2. La Toya - Give in. She is going to win.
3. Fantasia - Okay. Just okay for her. She's been losing her momentum since "Summertime"
4. Jasmine - absolutely terrible

2nd Set
----------
1. Diana - Once again, was my favorite. I finally understand why she was in the Final 12.
2. La Toya - Hmm... good!
3. Fantasia - Again... didn't get the song.
4. Jasmine - She's going home.

OVERALL
------------
1. Diana
2. LaToya
3. Fantasia
4. Jasmine
Title: American Idol
Post by: Alecs on May 12, 2004, 06:03:53 pm
I HATE THIS SHOW!!!! Who in the hell voted for Jasmine?!?!?! IDIOTS!!!!!

Latoya voted off is the stupidest!!! I never got through once to vote. I'm so pissed off!!! UUUUGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!!!!!! evil:
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 12, 2004, 06:17:56 pm
what the hell bitches??!?!?!?!?!!!?!??!?!?!?

this only proves my theory that people are stupid.

the end.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 12, 2004, 06:29:12 pm
ok...now i'm pissed.....


now....i'm not pissed that there was a huge surprise at the end, because Seacrest called that in the beginning of the show (when he said something to the effect of "welcome to the most unpredicatable show on t.v")

i figured that the bottom 2 would be Jaz and Fant, with the surprise being Fant going home, which i was hoping for.....

never.....and i mean NEEEEEEEEEEEEEVER would i expect the BEST singer in the whole friggen competition to get kicked off the show.....that's ridiculous



it's all Diana now....she's the only good one left....

EDIT:  oh....and btw....I CALLED IT....the crying thing worked.....see my post above.....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 12, 2004, 06:38:37 pm
I agree that LaToya shouldnt have gone, most definately it shoulda been Jasmine but- what I don't agree with some of you is that Fantasia should go... I'm sorry but Diana isn't that wonderful- yeah shes been pretty good lately, but... Fantasia most def has more star quality & a more unique voice- shes consistant
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 12, 2004, 09:28:35 pm
Wow, major shock tonight!
I didnt get to watch the show last night because I was at the Pepsi Smash taping! But my mom taped it for me and I got to watch it tonight before tonight's episode!
my order of faves:
1. Fantasia
2. Diana
3. LaToya
4. Jasmine

I was shocked when LaToya got voted off tonight!  8O
But though I was shocked... I wasn't dissapointed at all! Jasmine did deserve to go the most... but LaToya just seemed cocky to me, and I hate that, so I was kinda hoping she'd go too! I was so scared that it might have been Fantasia going home though and if it was I woulda thrown something at the TV, haha. But luckily they're safe...
Jasmine was lucky this week and she better step it up for the next week if she wants any chance of staying! But who knows, she could do a total turn around and gain respect back... but if not, it better be between Fantasia and Diana at the end!
Go Fantasia!! [/b]
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 13, 2004, 03:34:29 am
Quote from: "Holly"
But though I was shocked... I wasn't dissapointed at all! Jasmine did deserve to go the most... but LaToya just seemed cocky to me, and I hate that, so I was kinda hoping she'd go too!


EH????????


I don't think La Toya has ever seemed cocky.....thats one of the major reason's I don't like Fantasia....she's the most cocky of 'em all.....

La Toya was the classy one of the whole bunch.........
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 13, 2004, 05:05:19 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "Holly"
But though I was shocked... I wasn't dissapointed at all! Jasmine did deserve to go the most... but LaToya just seemed cocky to me, and I hate that, so I was kinda hoping she'd go too!


EH????????


I don't think La Toya has ever seemed cocky.....thats one of the major reason's I don't like Fantasia....she's the most cocky of 'em all.....

La Toya was the classy one of the whole bunch.........


I read an article when someone asked her if she was going home that night and she said something like "ofcourse not, it's not my time to go" Now it's ok being confident in yourself... but that comment just seemed rude to me, like she thought she was better than the rest of them and she deserved to stay more than them!
And how the heck is Fantasia cocky? lmao
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 13, 2004, 06:18:06 am
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "BWilli"
Quote from: "Holly"
But though I was shocked... I wasn't dissapointed at all! Jasmine did deserve to go the most... but LaToya just seemed cocky to me, and I hate that, so I was kinda hoping she'd go too!


EH????????


I don't think La Toya has ever seemed cocky.....thats one of the major reason's I don't like Fantasia....she's the most cocky of 'em all.....

La Toya was the classy one of the whole bunch.........


I read an article when someone asked her if she was going home that night and she said something like "ofcourse not, it's not my time to go" Now it's ok being confident in yourself... but that comment just seemed rude to me, like she thought she was better than the rest of them and she deserved to stay more than them!
And how the heck is Fantasia cocky? lmao


Fantasia has this attidute that I find hard to explain, and I dont like it....she just seems extremely cocky.....

I havent read that article, but what she said wasn't all that rude....i'm sure most of the contestants think they are better than the others....they may not express it, but i'm sure they think it.....

i don't think what she said there was rude....she simply said it wasn't her time.....many people can tell when it's there time.....like when Stevens finally got the boot....i'm sure he knew it would be him...he out stayed his welcome way longer than he should have.....

La Toya's stay was cut short, but about two weeks, cause she was definately the front runner to win these last few weeks....

but thats just my opinion, and believe me, i respect yours all the same... :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on May 13, 2004, 12:25:32 pm
I have a silly question: when does it end?
The french version ends tonight and the 2 guys left suck in my opinion.
Not that I really watch it, only like 20 min of the show each week! lol
But the girl who got voted off last week was really good compared to the 2 left.
Blah, silly french people who voted... :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on May 13, 2004, 12:29:28 pm
I've hated LaToya the most. I'm glad Jasmine got to stay and I thought she was was better than LaToya this time. LaToya did boring songs. She should stick to her showtunes. I was so happy. Diana is taking it.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 13, 2004, 05:29:29 pm
Quote from: "Ghisy"
I have a silly question: when does it end?
The french version ends tonight and the 2 guys left suck in my opinion.
Not that I really watch it, only like 20 min of the show each week! lol
But the girl who got voted off last week was really good compared to the 2 left.
Blah, silly french people who voted... :roll:



two more weeks i think....only three left, so next week they'll narrow it to two, then the following week will be the final
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 16, 2004, 09:23:51 pm
I managed to see Latoya go last night and what a blubbery mood i was in lol!
I cried when Jasmine cried and then i cried when my favorite person on Big Brother got booted 1st.
I wasnt very upset that Latoya went but I would of rathered Fantasia go.
Now i hope either Jasmine or Diana win, either one I would be happy with  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on May 17, 2004, 12:18:45 pm
The Tamyra Effect *Twilight Zone music* strikes for the second time this season.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 19, 2004, 05:00:41 am
1. Diana
2. Fantasia
3. Jasmine


Jasmine needs to go....she was better last night than last week, she can definately sing, but she's not as goo as Diana, or even Fantasia, who I really cant stand
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 19, 2004, 07:04:00 am
Jasmine was good, but she's definitely out of her league!
Diana was amazing last night! She has definitely grown in this compitition and I think no matter what happens she'll get a record contract and be big!
Fantasia was fantastic as usual last night! She's just continuously good!! I hope she wins, but like Paula said, she doesnt need the compition anymore, she's already a star!

1. Fantasia
2. Diana
3. Jasmine

I love her... but Jazzy better go home tonight!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 19, 2004, 07:07:00 am
a little birdie told me that Diana had the most votes nearly 3 weeks in a row....including last week
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 20, 2004, 03:37:28 am
down to two....Diana and Fantasia....


Diana all the way


is anyone still watching this show???
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 20, 2004, 03:53:57 am
i'm voting Fantasia, though I like Diana just as much :-)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Gina on May 20, 2004, 05:10:37 pm
my favs still in it, no matter what anyone else thinks.... FANTASIA should win, though idk if she will. Doesn't matter much now - she'll get a record deal :razz:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 20, 2004, 05:30:29 pm
Quote from: "Gina"
my favs still in it, no matter what anyone else thinks.... FANTASIA should win, though idk if she will. Doesn't matter much now - she'll get a record deal :razz:


ditto!
GO FANTASIA!!!!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 20, 2004, 09:26:28 pm
Did anyone leave tonight?
We had a news update over here and I saw that Guy Sebastian (Aus Idol)
performed his 1st singles Angels brought me here.
What did you guys think of it?
Also has anyone brought the American Idol cd? If you have i was wondering if you could possibly burn it or buy it for me? I would definately send you back something or of the same worth.
Thanks guys.
Channel 10 over here are airing The Final 3 tonight so i cant wait to see it.
I still think Diana is the best but Jasmine is very good aswell.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 22, 2004, 12:18:24 pm
I thought Guy was good! he reminded me of Craig David!
I thought of you when he was performing Katie! lol, i was like "Oh! that's the guy Katie was talking about!"
Title: American Idol
Post by: NESSAussie on May 23, 2004, 05:50:23 pm
Thanx 4 the props Holly! Its great Guy got the opportunity to perform there :D
(http://online-shrine.net/jasmine-trias/images/jasmine-trias.jpg)
 :roll: Sorry to see Jasmine's run come to an end; she had such enviable ambition

Quote
Why do you want to be an AMERICAN IDOL?

Because I think I have what it takes to make into the business. I’m a
strong person and I want to share all my talents with the rest of world.

I anticipate a record contract is only a matter of time! Dreams do come true 8)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Jophess on May 25, 2004, 05:13:19 pm
My votes (if I can get any through) go to Diana.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Laura on May 25, 2004, 07:30:54 pm
Yeah I'm rooting for Diana! I loved Fantasia at first but I'm in the middle of watching it now after her first performance & I actually agreed with Simon. Nobody wanted to hear it but it was kind of true! He was like "oh shutup people" haha.

I can't wait till tomorrows show!
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 26, 2004, 03:28:13 am
Diana got my votes....not many of them cause I still got a shite load of busy signals on all three numbers.....

Diana sang the first song (the one Tamyra wrote) extremely well....Simon shouldn't have criticized her on the type of song....she didn't write it or choose it....

Fantasia blew her first song....she ruined a normally pretty good song....

Diana's second two songs were great....I heard no flaws in the third song like the judges said......

Fantasia bored me with her second song, and was good with the third....but I still can't stand her voice.....
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on May 26, 2004, 10:11:37 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
Diana's second two songs were great....I heard no flaws in the third song like the judges said......


You must have not been listening very well. I totally didn't like her second song. She did well on the first one though.

Fantasia is obviously everyone's favorite on the show. I am not sure that the judges should be so vocal about it.

I saw an interview with Diana and she said she wasn't making excuses but it was a new venue and there were dead spots and all she could hear was the band, she couldn't hear herself and that made it hard.

I think that Fantasia is obviously the better singer. But the show is full of surprises so I guess we'll see.
Title: American Idol
Post by: divasteph on May 26, 2004, 10:49:51 am
i am pullin for my GA - girl diana - however i think fantasia will win
does it even matter at this point?
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 26, 2004, 10:56:28 am
Quote from: "eclv"
Quote from: "BWilli"
Diana's second two songs were great....I heard no flaws in the third song like the judges said......


You must have not been listening very well. I totally didn't like her second song. She did well on the first one though.


she was complemented on the second by the judges....she sang it better than a few weeks ago....just my opinion

Quote from: "divasteph"
does it even matter at this point?


nope
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 26, 2004, 12:23:10 pm
I'm rooting for Fantasia - i love Diana, but i just don't think she's as good as Fantasia - and last night proved it. I felt so bad, but Diana just wasn't as good as she has been - she was really out of tune and like screaching for the notes
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on May 26, 2004, 03:09:45 pm
So I heard on "On-Air" that there is just over a 1% difference.  8O

I don't think I can watch for two hours of all the random people especially if William Hung is going to be on. I think I will cheat and look here in a few hours.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Chloe on May 26, 2004, 05:55:33 pm
wheeeeeee GO DIANA!!! She's so awesome!

somehow i think Fantasia is going to win though...
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on May 26, 2004, 05:58:40 pm
HIGH POINT REPRESENT!!!!! GO FANTASIA THE PIEDMONT LOVES YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 26, 2004, 06:10:39 pm
Quote from: "LimeTwister"
HIGH POINT REPRESENT!!!!! GO FANTASIA THE PIEDMONT LOVES YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


woooooooot! oooh i'm so happy! *dances*
Title: American Idol
Post by: Chloe on May 26, 2004, 07:15:03 pm
awww Diana lost... oh well Fantasia deserved it!!! I'm happy for her!
Title: American Idol
Post by: Laura on May 26, 2004, 09:09:19 pm
Man this was like the hardest choice to make!! At first I liked Fantasia, then Diana, then at the end of last nights show I liked Fantasia again, lol

They both have good & bad nights singing but I'm glad Fantasia won. I was rooting for her tonight!

This is a little random but did you guys notice everybody from AI was there except for Justin Guarini? I saw him hosting VH1's top 20 & he looks freakin weird now & he acted like such a tool hosting it. It was so strange.
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 27, 2004, 03:12:41 am
i think a lot of people, whether they wanted Diana to win or not, knew deep down that Fantasia was gonna win....

Good for her (but I still can't stand her voice[i'm beginning to sound like a broken record])

Out of the rest, Diana and LaToya will definately get contracts anyway....
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on May 27, 2004, 04:27:21 am
Fantasia!


that's right all of you. i knew from the very first try-outs she was gonna win.

i called it!! i bet a lot of money on it! haha
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 27, 2004, 04:38:47 am
Quote from: "1vcfan"
Fantasia!


that's right all of you. i knew from the very first try-outs she was gonna win.

i called it!! i bet a lot of money on it! haha


so how much did you actually win then?
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on May 27, 2004, 10:59:59 am
30$!!!

hah i already bought a new skirt with it


here: take my quiz i JUST made! (its not tooo good hah)

http://quizilla.com/users/bigal0431/quizzes/Which%20American%20Idol%20are%20you%3F%20((2004))

((if anyone wants to make me images for the quiz, i would appreciate it! ))
Title: American Idol
Post by: JazzyManda on May 27, 2004, 11:35:18 am
ah, i'm upset. Diana should have won. tsk tsk. oh well

ATLEAST THEY'RE COMING TO ST. LOUIS NEXT YEAR!!!!!!!! AHHHHHH
hehe

Amanda
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on May 27, 2004, 12:44:20 pm
I've heard Fantasia on Kiis.
I'm not sure how she can be compared to Diana but I don't really dig her voice. I just heard one song, I might change my mind later though.
She's no Kelly! ;)
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 27, 2004, 12:49:43 pm
Quote from: "Ghisy"
I've heard Fantasia on Kiis.
I'm not sure how she can be compared to Diana but I don't really dig her voice. I just heard one song, I might change my mind later though.
She's no Kelly! ;)


she performed on the show last night - Beautiful Disaster. I actually liked it!
Title: American Idol
Post by: 1vcfan on May 27, 2004, 02:01:17 pm
im trying out for american idol when it comes to Cleveland- its only 10 minutes away from my house- i am SOOOOOO EXCITED
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 27, 2004, 08:29:26 pm
Fantasia? Poor Diana.
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on May 27, 2004, 08:46:39 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
I thought Guy was good! he reminded me of Craig David!
I thought of you when he was performing Katie! lol, i was like "Oh! that's the guy Katie was talking about!"

Hes an alright kinda guy. Im not into him much anymore.
But hes alright. Now whenever i hear or see Fantasia i will think of you Holls :)
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on May 27, 2004, 09:40:14 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Ghisy"
I've heard Fantasia on Kiis.
I'm not sure how she can be compared to Diana but I don't really dig her voice. I just heard one song, I might change my mind later though.
She's no Kelly! ;)


she performed on the show last night - Beautiful Disaster. I actually liked it!


huh? Fantasia sang a Kelly's song?
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 28, 2004, 03:30:40 am
Quote from: "Ghisy"
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "Ghisy"
I've heard Fantasia on Kiis.
I'm not sure how she can be compared to Diana but I don't really dig her voice. I just heard one song, I might change my mind later though.
She's no Kelly! ;)


she performed on the show last night - Beautiful Disaster. I actually liked it!


huh? Fantasia sang a Kelly's song?


no....she meant that Kelly was there and sang Beautiful Disaster...


WOW.....I just read that it was actually very close......Fantasia only won by 1% of the vote.....
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on May 28, 2004, 05:09:55 am
Quote from: "BWilli"
no....she meant that Kelly was there and sang Beautiful Disaster...


Oooooooh I need to download that part!!  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 28, 2004, 05:56:31 am
I am SO happy Fantasia won!!!  :D she's awesome! when you watch her perform you can always count on being entertained, cause not only does she do great on the song, but she puts so much emotion and personality into her performances! and she's so unique! I think she's the best american idol winner ever!  :D
Title: American Idol
Post by: BWilli on May 28, 2004, 06:12:40 am
eh.....she's kinna too dramatic in her performances.....

and why the hell does she have to add, "Yeah, Yeah Yeah" to the end of every friggen song.....that got old and annoying the second she started......
Title: American Idol
Post by: Ghisy on May 28, 2004, 07:52:50 am
Quote from: "Holly"
I think she's the best american idol winner ever!  :D


Tssk, tsssk, what about Kelly??  :wink:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on May 28, 2004, 02:02:02 pm
Quote from: "Ghisy"
Quote from: "Holly"
I think she's the best american idol winner ever!  :D


Tssk, tsssk, what about Kelly??  :wink:


I gotta agree with Ghis. Kelly can sing circles around Fantasia and Diana. I voted for Diana 10 times. I hate Fantasia because all she does is sing yeah yeah yeah.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 28, 2004, 03:36:25 pm
Quote from: "Steveau"
Quote from: "Ghisy"
Quote from: "Holly"
I think she's the best american idol winner ever!  :D


Tssk, tsssk, what about Kelly??  :wink:


I gotta agree with Ghis. Kelly can sing circles around Fantasia and Diana. I voted for Diana 10 times. I hate Fantasia because all she does is sing yeah yeah yeah.


I still think Fantasia is the best!
Kelly is awesome... just I like Fantasia more!
I never even noticed the "yeah, yeah, yeah's" lol, i guess i dont get annoyed easily!
Title: American Idol
Post by: eclv on May 28, 2004, 04:44:10 pm
I actually ended up watching and I am glad. I didn't care for the top 12's medly, it was horrible cheese!!

I really liked when Kelly, Diana, Fantasia and Ruben all sang together.

I like Diana but felt that Fantasia was the better singer. Like Holly I too never noticed the yeahs. She does have a different voice and everyone has their own opinions but she, like all the judges say is different. She is not as BV says, another wad of dough spewed out into the cookie cutter.

I think the thing I like most about her along with Vanessa is you can see her emotion in her songs.

I think they will all be fine AI or not.
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 28, 2004, 05:03:08 pm
Quote from: "eclv"


I think the thing I like most about her along with Vanessa is you can see her emotion in her songs.

I think they will all be fine AI or not.


i agree with both statements! like when Fantasia sings summertime and that one she dedicated to her daughter.....everything she's feeling just comes out!

and it's pretty obvious that diana will get a contract too, since a looooot of others have gotten contracts
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 28, 2004, 05:25:01 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "eclv"


I think the thing I like most about her along with Vanessa is you can see her emotion in her songs.

I think they will all be fine AI or not.


i agree with both statements! like when Fantasia sings summertime and that one she dedicated to her daughter.....everything she's feeling just comes out!


The thing I like most in artists is when they give out a lot of emotion and they're really feeling what they're singing cause it makes the music seem more real! and therefore you feel it too... atleast that's the way i feel!
for example, it's one of the main reasons I love National Product, I can't emplain how powerful their concerts are because of the emotion that Danny exudes. it's awesome!
You can tell Fantasia has it, Vanessa has it, Adam from Maroon5 has it... but I just dont see it in Diana... she has a powerful voice though.
Title: American Idol
Post by: LimeTwister on May 28, 2004, 05:36:32 pm
yes, i have noticed the more emotion you give the more the people like it.

if you can touch people, you can be seen as a better artist.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on May 28, 2004, 11:25:50 pm
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "eclv"


I think the thing I like most about her along with Vanessa is you can see her emotion in her songs.

I think they will all be fine AI or not.


i agree with both statements! like when Fantasia sings summertime and that one she dedicated to her daughter.....everything she's feeling just comes out!

and it's pretty obvious that diana will get a contract too, since a looooot of others have gotten contracts


I didn't feel anything when she sang. I was to busy counting the yeah's. She always got the sympathy of the voters because she always cried at the drop of a hat. I think Diana will sell more records than Fantasia.

To compare Fantasia with Vanessa or put them in the same sentence is an insult to Vanessa. IMHO
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 29, 2004, 12:16:13 am
Quote from: "Steveau"
I didn't feel anything when she sang. I was to busy counting the yeah's. She always got the sympathy of the voters because she always cried at the drop of a hat. I think Diana will sell more records than Fantasia.

To compare Fantasia with Vanessa or put them in the same sentence is an insult to Vanessa. IMHO


I really doubt Diana will out sell Fantasia! It was obvious it would happen with Ruben and Clay that the runner up would be more succesfull... cause Clay had something special just as Fantasia does too. Diana is a great singer but there is absolutely nothing unique about her... sure she has a great voice, but we already have a Xtina and a Kelly Clarkson who do the same thing but better.... There is no one like Fantasia out right now... so she'll sell more records.
And I put Nessa and Fantasia in the same sentence because they are both emotional singers. I didnt know calling Vanessa emotional was an insult... she feels what she sings, that's a good thing!
Title: American Idol
Post by: jlmusicchick on May 29, 2004, 07:01:39 am
Quote from: "Steveau"
Quote from: "jlmusicchick"
Quote from: "eclv"


I think the thing I like most about her along with Vanessa is you can see her emotion in her songs.

I think they will all be fine AI or not.


i agree with both statements! like when Fantasia sings summertime and that one she dedicated to her daughter.....everything she's feeling just comes out!

and it's pretty obvious that diana will get a contract too, since a looooot of others have gotten contracts


I didn't feel anything when she sang. I was to busy counting the yeah's. She always got the sympathy of the voters because she always cried at the drop of a hat. I think Diana will sell more records than Fantasia.

To compare Fantasia with Vanessa or put them in the same sentence is an insult to Vanessa. IMHO


to each his own :-P i like both diana and fantasia, i would have been happy with either of them winning! i'm curious as to what kind of music diana is going to do, since i don't think she was that strong when she had to sing the gospel/r&b-type music for the finale...i really liked her when they did the big band one, i think those were her strongest performances
Title: American Idol
Post by: Steveau on May 29, 2004, 03:16:39 pm
Quote from: "Holly"
Quote from: "Steveau"
I didn't feel anything when she sang. I was to busy counting the yeah's. She always got the sympathy of the voters because she always cried at the drop of a hat. I think Diana will sell more records than Fantasia.

To compare Fantasia with Vanessa or put them in the same sentence is an insult to Vanessa. IMHO


I really doubt Diana will out sell Fantasia! It was obvious it would happen with Ruben and Clay that the runner up would be more succesfull... cause Clay had something special just as Fantasia does too. Diana is a great singer but there is absolutely nothing unique about her... sure she has a great voice, but we already have a Xtina and a Kelly Clarkson who do the same thing but better.... There is no one like Fantasia out right now... so she'll sell more records.
And I put Nessa and Fantasia in the same sentence because they are both emotional singers. I didnt know calling Vanessa emotional was an insult... she feels what she sings, that's a good thing!

I didn't say calling Vanessa emotional was an insult just that comparing Fantasia to her is because they aren't in the same league.
Title: American Idol
Post by: Holly on May 29, 2004, 04:18:58 pm
Quote from: "Steveau"
I didn't say calling Vanessa emotional was an insult just that comparing Fantasia to her is because they aren't in the same league.


lol, i never said they're in the same league. i just said they're both emotional singers...  :roll:
Title: American Idol
Post by: Laura on May 31, 2004, 04:46:38 pm
Dang this discussion is getting heated, lol

I think for once in AI they BOTH will do well. But for some reason I think Diana will SELL more & probably do more popish stuff but Fantasia will BE BETTER if that makes sense.

I personally love them both. I think that Diana is an excellent singer but Fantasia really connects with people.
Title: American Idol
Post by: aleera84 on June 01, 2004, 09:10:27 pm
Diana should try out for Australian Idol, haha I wish she would move here.