NESSAholics.com
Vanessa Carlton => General Vanessa Carlton Discussion => Topic started by: tylor2000 on January 11, 2004, 12:34:31 am
-
What songs in your opinion(or do you hope) are going to be on the album Harmonium? Keeping in mind we don't know at least some of the songs which will be going onto it.
For instance, is Private Radio still going to be on it? What are the old songs you think she decided a while back to take off? How many tracks do you think it will be?
tylor
-
I heard she was going to get rid of Papa, but I really hope that doesn't happen!! Papa has the most amazing piano part, and it's so amazing live! I can't wait to hear all the new stuff like 'Private Radio'. I hope songs like Superhero will be on too!
:D So excited hehe.
xoxox
(http://img8.photobucket.com/albums/v28/freakytiafreak/Other%20peoples/georgiesig2.gif)
-
Personally I'd love to see some of the demo songs given the full studio treatment, as some of them sound fantastic just as they are. I don't think that's very likely though.
-
I heard she was going to get rid of Papa, but I really hope that doesn't happen!!
where did you hear that?
-
The Vcmb....! lol. This was ages ago though, I'm sure she would never take that song of though!!! So please don't belive it because I could have missed heard! lol.
xox
(http://img8.photobucket.com/albums/v28/freakytiafreak/Other%20peoples/georgiesig2.gif)
-
Georgie, here's a lesson in life...
Do NOT trust the VCMB. It's a rumor, not a fact, and the fact that it was on the VCMB makes it even less likely. Ah well... I hope that today, Georgie, you learned a valuable thing. :spin:
-
Georgie, here's a lesson in life...
Do NOT trust the VCMB. It's a rumor, not a fact, and the fact that it was on the VCMB makes it even less likely. Ah well... I hope that today, Georgie, you learned a valuable thing. :spin:
sad, but true.
i hope she doesn't cut afterglow (i think that one was going on it) or c'est la vie, but we'll just have to wait and see. oh and i agree with the person who said that the demos should be givin the full studio treatment. that would be freakin awesome.
-
i think private radio will still be on, since it was going to be the first single, which shows that she must really favor it. I think if any songs were going to be taken off, it would be Swindler or C'est La Vie. Though I love both those songs, they aren't my favorite, so it's more of a personal assumption than anything else. I really hope she doesn't get rid of Bridie an Afterglow!
Ooo and i don't think she's going to have superhero, since she basically told mike (lostdwarf) at the SUCO show that she was done with it. I'm hoping that what my sis heard wasn't true, and that she'll have more than 10 tracks on Harmonium, but who knows?
-
1. C'est La Vie
2. Instert 1st Single here
3. She Floats
4. Private Radio
5. San Francisco
6. Papa
7. Insert 2nd new song (delayer)
8. Morning Sting
9. Insert New Song Here (already recorded, not a delayer)
10. Ameriteen
That's what I came up with. She said 10 songs, sooo...
-
the ones i'm pretty sure will be on there are C'est la Vie, Papa, She Floats, Sanfransico, and Private Radio. then those two new ones, and then i guess 3 other ones. lol. i really don't think Afterglow, Birdie, or Ameriteen will be on there, don't ask me why but i just kind of doubt it. i think swindler is out too.
it'd be cool if Superhero were on there, but that's probably not going to happen.
Amanda
-
look for:
C'est La Vie
Papa
Afterglow
San Francisco
Morning Sting
to be on the cd, cause that most likely will happen since they recorded her playing them at the dvd taping.
others that most likely will be on the cd:
Private Radio
She Floats
Ameriteen
anything else, DO NOT BELIEVE.
-
When did she say that there were only going to be 10 songs?
I'm praying that she might include the final version of Dark Carnival...
-
When did she say that there were only going to be 10 songs?
I'm praying that she might include the final version of Dark Carnival...
...yeah, when did she say that there were only going to be 10 songs????
&
The final version of Dark Carnival was already released. why would she put it on her cd??
it just came out on a videogame.
and since its the THEME SONG to that video game, you can bet it will only be availible on that video game.
-
i don't think Ameriteen will be on there. and if it is released, i think it will be a B-Side, like Swindler.
-
Lmao! It is so sad, but so true Joey I know! Thank you for help clearing my mind!!! *hugs* And yes I learnt that is was rumours, I mean Papa is a legend! xoxoxoxox
(http://mars.walagata.com/w/nagyovafan/georgiesig.jpg)
-
I hope she floats makes it, c'est la vie, and papa...birdie is so old I really doubt they're even thinking about putting it on the album..
I haven't heard Ameriteen....well i have but I don't remember it.
-
I feel certain about She Floats, C'est La Vie, and Papa
I'd LOVE to say Ameriteen because that is my favorite of all the new songs, but I just don't think it's likely.
I hope she drops Afterglow. I really really do.
But yeah.. I hope she puts more new songs than songs that we already know.. it'd be fun.. but also, I'm curious to see how the old new songs sound recorded!!
-
I can't wait, I want it to be a suprise!!!
*closes eyes*
Manda
(prepare to be amazed, all!)
-
dont expect the dark carnival
you will see...
afterglow
she floats
papa
C'est la vie
morning sting
sanfransico
pirate radio
and 2 new singles
you might see(depending on what she took off).....
amerateen
doubtfully...
swindler
birdy
-
dont expect the dark carnival
you will see...
afterglow
she floats
papa
C'est la vie
morning sting
sanfransico
pirate radio
you might see(depending on what she took off).....
amerateen
doubtfully...
swindler
birdy
Agrees, but hopes for many more songs!!!!
Wouldn't it be great if she just busted out a double disk?!?!?!? I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
-
I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
Are you kidding?! lmao, i plan on buying two of whatever she releases. One for my house, and one to put in my purse for wherever i am :-P *is so excited*
-
I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
Are you kidding?! lmao, i plan on buying two of whatever she releases. One for my house, and one to put in my purse for wherever i am :-P *is so excited*
Agreed!
Manda
-
I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
Are you kidding?! lmao, i plan on buying two of whatever she releases. One for my house, and one to put in my purse for wherever i am :-P *is so excited*
yea, i don't see why Alecs doesn't buy one for his purse... ;)
-
I hope its more than 10 songs! She has so many songs floating around... darnit!
-
i would just like to also say that i agree with nicole, there needs to be more songs, i don't think birdie will be recorded, nor superhero however it was strange she played it at the USNA and i think afterglow will be on it and i'm pretty sure steve is most correct with his guesses.
-katia
-
yea... I'd be majorly shocked if superhero turned up on the CD....
I STILL do not undertsand the fascination with that song!
-
yea... I'd be majorly shocked if superhero turned up on the CD....
I STILL do not undertsand the fascination with that song!
I just have a soft place in my heart for it cause its the first quote unquote rare VC track I ever got.
It is a beautiful song, but doesnt fit who she is today.
-
yea... I'd be majorly shocked if superhero turned up on the CD....
I STILL do not undertsand the fascination with that song!
I just have a soft place in my heart for it cause its the first quote unquote rare VC track I ever got.
It is a beautiful song, but doesnt fit who she is today.
well... what about everyone else?
-
I <3 Superhero.
-
I <3 Superhero.
:spank:
-
I <3 Superhero.
:spank:
oooOOooo spank me! err i man... ouch!
-
I <3 Superhero.
:spank:
oooOOooo spank me! err i man... ouch!
you dirty lil thing!
-
I <3 Superhero.
:spank:
oooOOooo spank me! err i man... ouch!
you dirty lil thing!
LOL!
-
teehee
so umm back to HARMONIUM...
-
teehee
so umm back to HARMONIUM...
Yeah... :roll:
-
I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
Are you kidding?! lmao, i plan on buying two of whatever she releases. One for my house, and one to put in my purse for wherever i am :-P *is so excited*
yea, i don't see why Alecs doesn't buy one for his purse... ;)
haha you know what i mean. anyways, i love superhero. i made a slide show of my pics from the SUCO show with superhero playing the back ground :oops: I agree with BV, it doesn't seem to fit her style now, but i think it is still a great song regardless!
-
yea... I'd be majorly shocked if superhero turned up on the CD....
I STILL do not undertsand the fascination with that song!
I just have a soft place in my heart for it cause its the first quote unquote rare VC track I ever got.
It is a beautiful song, but doesnt fit who she is today.
well... what about everyone else?
AGREES*** :o
...sure i understand if vanessa doesn't want to put superhero or any other old unreleaced song on the album... but i think she should, or at least on ONE of her CDs.. i mean she needs to consider that people hear her songs, and those songs might relate to those people in some way, and it could get them to be better fans.. or attract new/more fans.
I think she should re-make Little Mary. ...that song is amazing, and i can only imagine the sweetness that it could be. 8O
i'd like to hear every one of her songs be on an Album. whenever, i dont care, i just want the old songs on a new cd :(
i remember in one of vanessa's posts she said something like she had 'enough songs for 4 albums' or something... sure she might have been exxagerating(or im not rememberring correctally), but does that mean she will eventually put those olds songs on a cd in the future? hmmm, im also sure she has like 923871203984702938 secret songs that she tells noone about. ...ohhhh, i want to hear them all :oops:
-
i think she should remake little mary last fall and faces
-
I don't think I would leave my house for months. 8O
Are you kidding?! lmao, i plan on buying two of whatever she releases. One for my house, and one to put in my purse for wherever i am :-P *is so excited*
yea, i don't see why Alecs doesn't buy one for his purse... ;)
Bwaa haa haa!!! That's true Katia. My wallet isn't that big! :D
-
yea... I'd be majorly shocked if superhero turned up on the CD....
I STILL do not undertsand the fascination with that song!
I just have a soft place in my heart for it cause its the first quote unquote rare VC track I ever got.
It is a beautiful song, but doesnt fit who she is today.
well... what about everyone else?
AGREES*** :o
...sure i understand if vanessa doesn't want to put superhero or any other old unreleaced song on the album... but i think she should...
I think she should re-make Little Mary.
Superhero is un-effing-believable! One of my faves. I would really really like to hear her play it live. When she didn't play it on the tour last time in spite of a lot of demand that was a sign. It was a different time in her life and as awesome as the piano and song is, I am guessing vanessa considers it so over.
*sobs*
about some of the demo songs. I agree there are some pretty good ones and I guess Little Mary is one, along with Faces and Last Fall, but the one I like the best is Meggie Sue. That one really was awesome, though I don't really know what the heck she was talking about (though I have a couple of ideas), but the quality of her voice and the piano, as simple as it was, was amazing, I could not get enough of it at first. It was like BNN at first. What is that about Vanessa and some of her songs. Can someone 'xplain that to me?
-
she's so going to blow us away!
Manda
-
she's so going to blow us away!
Does she ever fail to amaze? :D
We :heart: Nessa!!
-
i doubt she would bring back superhero because she said that she just made 2 new songs,
now we have to find out what new means is that re make an old song or is it to make a entirely new one? we must find out!
also the only slow song is sanfransico and that get slightly fast and dark at the end and during the bridge. that is the only slow song that should be on it with the exception of the "new songs" they might not be new she may have just re-made them, but someone will have to ask her :D .
also they probaly are dark to go with the whole sceme of the cd
steve
P.S. Did any one find out what the DVD is going to be called?
-
P.S. Did any one find out what the DVD is going to be called?
if it comes with every one of the CDs, then it probally won't have a name, or it will be named something like "The Making Of Harmonium"
...if we have to buy it seppretally, then it might have a cool name with more thought.
but im just guessing.. i have no idea.
i guess we'll just have to wait and see...
-
I <3 Superhero.
:spank:
oh but it's a lovely song!
*please don't spank me...or maybe you shou...nvm*
-
P.S. Did any one find out what the DVD is going to be called?
if it comes with every one of the CDs, then it probally won't have a name, or it will be named something like "The Making Of Harmonium"
...if we have to buy it seppretally, then it might have a cool name with more thought.
but im just guessing.. i have no idea.
i guess we'll just have to wait and see...
it is vanesa i don't think that she would do that she works differentaly i wonder if it realy is going to say goth in relation to vanessa i know that normal people would not want to listen to goth music i would not and then the gothic people would not like it because it isnot gothic at all ok maby i jsut have it in my heas but i don't know i would not want to listen to it if it said gothic in relations to her that would freak me out
-
NO OFFECE TO GOTHIC PEOPLE !!!!!!! :oops:
-
When did she say that there were only going to be 10 songs?
I'm praying that she might include the final version of Dark Carnival...
...yeah, when did she say that there were only going to be 10 songs????
I remember in a post many moons ago when she first started talking about VC2 that she might put 10 tracks on it. I hope she's changed her mind!
I doubt that Superhero or Ameriteen will be on the album. At the time when she performed Ameriteen we were dead on into the war, and even though it's still very dangerous and things are in a fragile state over there, I think it's past that point when she first wrote it now. Same with Superhero, it doesn't fit her style anymore.
I do like the prospect of spiffing up some of the demos. Don't think it will happen any time soon.
As for me, I'd like to have...
Swindler
Papa
C'est la Vie
Afterglow
Birdie
Although a whole album of brand new tunes would be groovy too!
-
P.S. Did any one find out what the DVD is going to be called?
if it comes with the CDs, then it probally won't have a name, or it will be named something like "The Making Of Harmonium"
It should come with the CD.
This is what I got . . .
My name is Gavin Booth and I'm working on editing together Vanessa's DVD that will come included with her new album
-
It should come with the CD.
This is what I got . . .
My name is Gavin Booth and I'm working on editing together Vanessa's DVD that will come included with her new album
That would be so awesome!! And it's not even that long 'til March either!! :blob:
-
wait--March?
-
wait--March?
*stops jumping and looks alarmed*
What? :?
-
wait--March?
*stops jumping and looks alarmed*
What? :?
vanessa said june, not march...
...but who knows when the single will be out :? :roll:
oooooooooooh im SOOOOOOOO excited :x
-
wait--March?
*stops jumping and looks alarmed*
What? :?
vanessa said june, not march...
Oh damn...
How the hell did I twist it into March?! 8O :cry:
-
tia- the cd was origionally going to be out in the march/april area, but then she pushed everything back because she wrote two new songs :wink:
-
tia- the cd was origionally going to be out in the march/april area, but then she pushed everything back because she wrote two new songs :wink:
Yeah...I know...
It was probably very strong wishful thinking :roll:
Oh how desperate I am...
-
I thought Tia had news I didn't. . . dammit!
-
I thought Tia had news I didn't. . . dammit!
lol...sorry C...
-
Awwww!
That's okay we'll wait together. . . and knit. Because knitting is fun!! (not really but time consuming yes)
-
Awwww!
That's okay we'll wait together. . . and knit. Because knitting is fun!! (not really but time consuming yes)
Knitting is good... =)
-
i dont understand why only 10 songs?
she has a lot more than that that im sure shed like to put on
maybe cos of time? hmm
-
no she has more than enulf but she does not want to give every thing out at once ...does that mean that is going to happen maby 5 years down the line 3 cds later a greatest hits comes out with older songs possibly? :D
but don't qoute that i jsut think it would be cool
-
Im sure Vanessa would like to be releasing 2 albums a year with 15 songs on each...unfortunately there are record companies and their marketing strategies.
1 album .......2 years ......10 or 11 songs. Thats the way its gonna stay.
Anyway, how are you all? :D
James
-
ohh yea i know that james but i was just wishful thinking lol
grea t you? :D
-
Dandy :D
-
ok this is what i think it is going to be
1.afterglow
2. (other song inspired by a blizard)
3.Private radio ( i don't know)
4.White Houses(i don't know)
5.Ameriteen (definatly solo)
6.Morning Sting (solo)
7.Papa (solo)
8.San Fransico (solo hopefully)
9.(cover if she makes one)
10. she floats ( duet with some one)
-
ok this is what i think it is going to be
1.afterglow
2. (other song inspired by a blizard)
3.Private radio ( i don't know)
4.White Houses(i don't know)
5.Ameriteen (definatly solo)
6.Morning Sting (solo)
7.Papa (solo)
8.San Fransico (solo hopefully)
9.(cover if she makes one)
10. she floats ( duet with some one)
more like:
1Private Radio
2Morning Sting
3C'est La Vie
4White Houses
5Papa
6San Francisco
7Ameriteen
8She Floats
9Afterglow
10[title not known|the other new song she wrote]
11[Quail Dude Squaw -- not final name, but working name -- from the interview http://www.nessaholics.com/pages/katia_tricia_interview_aug_7.html ]
----------
and there most likely will be more than 10 songs :?
-
Looks about right, but is Ameriteen still going to be on Harmonium? I think I remember reading somewhere that it's off...or am I just being schizophrenic? :roll:
-
I don't think Ameriteen will be on there...it was just mostly about the start of the war in Iraq and although there is still a war being faught over there it's not the right time to put out a war song...you know?
-
I don't think Ameriteen will be on there...it was just mostly about the start of the war in Iraq and although there is still a war being faught over there it's not the right time to put out a war song...you know?
its a great song, it doesn't matter if theres a war going on or not! :roll:
-
I still doubt it will make it.
-
I don't ever remember anyone, Vanessa or management, stating that Ameriteen was planned for VC2. Did I miss it? And I remember she was trying to get Neil Young to play on "Floats" with her, I still hope so!
-
I HOPE Ameriteen makes it.
..it's doubtful
but still.. it's one of my favorites (if not my favorite) of the new batch of songs (the ones i've heard)
-
I don't think Ameriteen will be on there...it was just mostly about the start of the war in Iraq and although there is still a war being faught over there it's not the right time to put out a war song...you know?
its a great song, it doesn't matter if theres a war going on or not! :roll:
ya but what artist in their right mind would put out a song about a war when there isn't a war going on. It will be a bomb like Madonna's song...American life??
-
ok this is what i think it is going to be
1.afterglow
2. (other song inspired by a blizard)
3.Private radio ( i don't know)
4.White Houses(i don't know)
5.Ameriteen (definatly solo)
6.Morning Sting (solo)
7.Papa (solo)
8.San Fransico (solo hopefully)
9.(cover if she makes one)
10. she floats ( duet with some one)
more like:
1Private Radio
2Morning Sting
3C'est La Vie
4White Houses
5Papa
6San Francisco
7Ameriteen
8She Floats
9Afterglow
10[title not known|the other new song she wrote]
11[Quail Dude Squaw -- not final name, but working name -- from the interview http://www.nessaholics.com/pages/katia_tricia_interview_aug_7.html ]
----------
and there most likely will be more than 10 songs :?
If you kept reading it says that that is NOT the name of the song also i don't think that she would put it like that with papa so early and like all the fast songs in the beging and also i don't think ameriteen will be on we both messed up the person that said that she took it off might be right i think it could be a b-side
-
If you kept reading it says that that is NOT the name of the song also i don't think that she would put it like that with papa so early and like all the fast songs in the beging and also i don't think ameriteen will be on we both messed up the person that said that she took it off might be right i think it could be a b-side
If you kept reading you'd see that HE said it wasn't the name of the song :roll:
-
If you kept reading it says that that is NOT the name of the song also i don't think that she would put it like that with papa so early and like all the fast songs in the beging and also i don't think ameriteen will be on we both messed up the person that said that she took it off might be right i think it could be a b-side
If you kept reading you'd see that HE said it wasn't the name of the song :roll:
sentence does my you read make sense, with be force may you the
-
If you kept reading it says that that is NOT the name of the song also i don't think that she would put it like that with papa so early and like all the fast songs in the beging and also i don't think ameriteen will be on we both messed up the person that said that she took it off might be right i think it could be a b-side
If you kept reading you'd see that HE said it wasn't the name of the song :roll:
sentence does my you read make sense, with be force may you the
C's sentence makes perfect scence, if you didnt understand it,.... well, i'll be nice and sum it up..
i said 11[Quail Dude Squaw -- not final name, but working name -- from the interview http://www.nessaholics.com/pages/katia_tricia_interview_aug_7.html ]
then blueglove said 'if you kept on reading it siad it isnt the name of the song'
then TSE said in reply to blueglove 'if you kept on reading, you'd notice that Andrew[me] said that 'quail dude squaw' wasnt the final name to that song.'
blah blah blah blah blah blah blah!!!!! 8O :?
-
C's sentence makes perfect scence, if you didnt understand it,.... well, i'll be nice and sum it up..
It wasn't C's sentence I was saying that didn't make sense :?
-
Andrew and Scotty love me! :D
-
Andrew and Scotty love me! :D
who doesnt :D
-
i think it would b soooo ausome if she put some of her earlier songs on there as well. does ne1 have her newer stuff on mp3, like papa and all those? i would really luv 2 have those!
-
1Private Radio
2Morning Sting
3C'est La Vie
4White Houses
5Papa
6San Francisco
7Ameriteen
8She Floats
9Afterglow
10[title not known|the other new song she wrote]
11[Quail Dude Squaw -- not final name, but working name -- from the interview http://www.nessaholics.com/pages/katia_tricia_interview_aug_7.html ]
I just read that interview again, and I came across a passage that I found interesting:
...There's actually two new songs on the album that no one's ever heard before...[R]ight now [one]'s being called "Quail Dude Squaw...
Before there were the two blizzard songs (of which White Houses is one), there were these two new songs...one of them the Interlude/Qualylude/Quail Dude Squaw that she mentioned as being hard to play in the interview, and which Kulp included above in his list. The other she simply refers to as a "new song that no one's ever heard before"...therefore, assuming that Ameriteen is off, there will be 11 tracks on Harmonium:
1. Morning Sting
2. C'est La Vie
3. Papa
4. Quail Dude Squaw
5. (Second totally new song)
6. San Fransisco
7. White Houses
8. Private Radio
9. (Second Blizzard Song)
10. She Floats
11. Afterglow
The second totally new song takes the place of Ameriteen.
Of course, then there's Nessa's post from the o-board saying that she "just wrote two new songs that are bumping some old ones off". These two new songs that she had just written are the blizzard songs, of course. The question that this raises, however, is the one that has never been answered: what are the "old ones" that got bumped off? From the surmised track lists that we can come up with, all songs likely to be on Harmonium, even without the blizzard-bumping :razz:, are present and accounted for. Plus, in the interview already mentioned twice above, when asked if there would be any old songs on Harmonium, Vanessa replied "...Afterglow's kinda old..." If you read that section of the interview, it seems to say that Afterglow is the oldest song on the album. Everything else that might be deemed old (e.g. Papa, C'est La Vie) she's performed live, and therefore isn't really "old". Plus, even if Afterglow, Papa, C'est La Vie, or She Floats were considered old enough for two of them to be the "old ones" being bumped off, then there would have to be two more completely new songs on Harmonium that she hasn't told anyone about yet....
Now, as I was just writing that, it suddenly dawned on me that that's a very real possiblility. While it seems unlikely to me that any of the four "old" songs mentioned above would comprise the two bumbped off, if they do, then there must have been, at the time of the interview, two more completely new songs in the works, which would now be providing the extra songs needed to make at least 11 tracks on Harmonium. (this assumes that there will be at least 11 tracks)
What I had originally intended to claim is that there were two more completely new songs in the works, and those have now been bumped off in favor of the blizzard pair.
So, in conclusion of perhaps the longest post in my life, it seems to me (seems to me, mind you, this is a fairly presumptuous leap on my part, I think) that there are the two most likely possible track lists for Harmonium:
A. What I have listed toward the beginning of this post, in which case two completely new songs, never heard and never mentioned (besides the post saying that two old ones were bumped off), are the ones being bumped off Harmonium
B. What I have listed, except minus two of the "old", but not really "old" songs: Afterglow, Papa, C'est La Vie, etc.
* * *
I'm hoping that it's A. Of course, as I said earlier, this is very presumptuous on my part, I think...and plus, I sort of changed my conclusion mid-post, so I'm not sure how sturdy this opinion is...
-
1Private Radio
2Morning Sting
3C'est La Vie
4White Houses
5Papa
6San Francisco
7Ameriteen
8She Floats
9Afterglow
10[title not known|the other new song she wrote]
11[Quail Dude Squaw -- not final name, but working name -- from the interview http://www.nessaholics.com/pages/katia_tricia_interview_aug_7.html ]
I just read that interview again, and I came across a passage that I found interesting:
...There's actually two new songs on the album that no one's ever heard before...[R]ight now [one]'s being called "Quail Dude Squaw...
Before there were the two blizzard songs (of which White Houses is one), there were these two new songs...one of them the Interlude/Qualylude/Quail Dude Squaw that she mentioned as being hard to play in the interview, and which Kulp included above in his list. The other she simply refers to as a "new song that no one's ever heard before"...therefore, assuming that Ameriteen is off, there will be 11 tracks on Harmonium:
1. Morning Sting
2. C'est La Vie
3. Papa
4. Quail Dude Squaw
5. (Second totally new song)
6. San Fransisco
7. White Houses
8. Private Radio
9. (Second Blizzard Song)
10. She Floats
11. Afterglow
The second totally new song takes the place of Ameriteen.
Of course, then there's Nessa's post from the o-board saying that she "just wrote two new songs that are bumping some old ones off". These two new songs that she had just written are the blizzard songs, of course. The question that this raises, however, is the one that has never been answered: what are the "old ones" that got bumped off? From the surmised track lists that we can come up with, all songs likely to be on Harmonium, even without the blizzard-bumping :razz:, are present and accounted for. Plus, in the interview already mentioned twice above, when asked if there would be any old songs on Harmonium, Vanessa replied "...Afterglow's kinda old..." If you read that section of the interview, it seems to say that Afterglow is the oldest song on the album. Everything else that might be deemed old (e.g. Papa, C'est La Vie) she's performed live, and therefore isn't really "old". Plus, even if Afterglow, Papa, C'est La Vie, or She Floats were considered old enough for two of them to be the "old ones" being bumped off, then there would have to be two more completely new songs on Harmonium that she hasn't told anyone about yet....
Now, as I was just writing that, it suddenly dawned on me that that's a very real possiblility. While it seems unlikely to me that any of the four "old" songs mentioned above would comprise the two bumbped off, if they do, then there must have been, at the time of the interview, two more completely new songs in the works, which would now be providing the extra songs needed to make at least 11 tracks on Harmonium. (this assumes that there will be at least 11 tracks)
What I had originally intended to claim is that there were two more completely new songs in the works, and those have now been bumped off in favor of the blizzard pair.
So, in conclusion of perhaps the longest post in my life, it seems to me (seems to me, mind you, this is a fairly presumptuous leap on my part, I think) that there are the two most likely possible track lists for Harmonium:
A. What I have listed toward the beginning of this post, in which case two completely new songs, never heard and never mentioned (besides the post saying that two old ones were bumped off), are the ones being bumped off Harmonium
B. What I have listed, except minus two of the "old", but not really "old" songs: Afterglow, Papa, C'est La Vie, etc.
* * *
I'm hoping that it's A. Of course, as I said earlier, this is very presumptuous on my part, I think...and plus, I sort of changed my conclusion mid-post, so I'm not sure how sturdy this opinion is...
or maybe the song getting knocked off the list is the 'new' Interlude.
and not ameriteen?
huh..
you didnt think of that now did you.
or maybe ...just maybe..
there are 12 songs on the CD.. or 13, or 14 or 15!!?!?!
huH?
maybe she'll release the songs she 'took off the list' on the new singles CD's .......hmmmmm.....
-
hopefully there's more than 10 though... :?
-
Maybe "White House" is about how George W. Bush won't be re-elected.
-
Maybe "White House" is about how George W. Bush won't be re-elected.
or maybe its not.
GO PRESIDENT GEORGE BUSH! WOOO!!!!! :twisted:
[just because you dont like him] :D
nahh, its most likely about sex. :twisted: