NESSAholics.com

Vanessa Carlton => General Vanessa Carlton Discussion => Topic started by: BWilli on July 23, 2004, 04:36:37 am

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: BWilli on July 23, 2004, 04:36:37 am

sorry if this was posted, but I saw it up on another website....

http://www.popdirt.com/modules.php?name=Surveys&op=results&pollID=94

she's currently in last place   :x

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Blake on July 23, 2004, 07:02:08 am

Voted, whored it on AIM and posted it here: http://www.livejournal.com/community/vanessacarlton/ since I didn't think you had an LJ...  :D

She's currently tied with Stacie Orrico and Hilary Duff with 21 votes.

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: BWilli on July 23, 2004, 07:03:57 am

Quote from: "Blake"

She's currently tied with Stacie Orrico and Hilary Duff with 21 votes.

what an insult   :razz:    no offense to you Duff and Orrico fans

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: sayyouwould on July 23, 2004, 09:04:40 am

Stacie Orrico has an amazing voice...what are you talking about?

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: BWilli on July 23, 2004, 09:14:09 am

Quote from: "sayyouwould"

Stacie Orrico has an amazing voice...what are you talking about?

i'm not such a fan....and did you read the fine print....i meant no offense the fans of those singers[/url]

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: tylor2000 on July 23, 2004, 12:31:10 pm

voted.

How often can you vote?

tylor

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Tia on July 23, 2004, 12:34:23 pm

V's not really AI material, in my opinion. She's better doing her own thang... 8)

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: BWilli on July 23, 2004, 12:41:04 pm

Quote from: "tylor2000"

voted.

How often can you vote?

tylor

don't know...i only voted once...didn't try again

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: tylor2000 on July 23, 2004, 12:45:50 pm

Quote from: "BWilli"

Quote from: "tylor2000"

voted.

How often can you vote?

tylor

don't know...i only voted once...didn't try again

I did.  I think once per day.  It didn't let me vote again.  We'll see.

tylor

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: vt on July 23, 2004, 01:01:46 pm

I voted for Christina.

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Tia on July 23, 2004, 01:02:19 pm

Quote from: "prettybaby!"

I voted for Christina.

Traitor! Off w' yur 'ed!! :-P

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: vt on July 23, 2004, 01:06:02 pm

Quote from: "Tia"

Quote from: "prettybaby!"

I voted for Christina.

Traitor! Off w' yur 'ed!! :-P

lol......Well I think Christina Aguilera would win!  But just 'cause I'm also a Vanessa fan, I'll vote for her as well too...tomorrow!

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Tia on July 23, 2004, 01:11:09 pm

Yay :)

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Manda on July 23, 2004, 01:11:59 pm

Honestly. I dont think she would win.  8O

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: LifelessPie on July 23, 2004, 01:15:14 pm

Quote from: "Tia"

V's not really AI material, in my opinion. She's better doing her own thang... 8)

*agrees with Tia*

oh yea and VOOOOOTEEEEEEEEEEED.


 :D

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Manda on July 23, 2004, 01:17:07 pm

Quote from: "Tia"

V's not really AI material, in my opinion. She's better doing her own thang... 8)

Duh! My mama is soooooooooo smart. she knows her stuff.  :razz:

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Tia on July 24, 2004, 07:46:08 am

I'm just good at stating the obvious :wink:

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Blake on July 24, 2004, 08:00:48 am

Quote from: "Tia"

Quote from: "prettybaby!"

I voted for Christina.

Traitor! Off w' yur 'ed!! :-P

I agree it shall happen at noon! (heh 7 minutes, hell yeah!)

Also it's not like Christina Aguilara has a good chance of losing to anyone especially VC when CA already has 1210 and VC has 44

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Tia on July 24, 2004, 08:01:47 am

LOL!

Someone find an axe!

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: clamicas on July 24, 2004, 06:18:34 pm

Quote from: "LifelessPie"

Quote from: "Tia"

V's not really AI material, in my opinion. She's better doing her own thang... 8)

*agrees with Tia*

oh yea and VOOOOOTEEEEEEEEEEED.


 :D

*also agrees *

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: Moogs21 on July 24, 2004, 09:54:03 pm

Do I personally think she would win?

No... I think she'd stay for awhile, but now win.
I respect V for her piano playing just as much as her voice.

To be fair, 99.9% of pop stars wouldn't win on AI.

I think Christina would win, and would deserve it.

But because I love V, she's getting my vote. She deserves it more than other people that are ahead of her.

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: vt on July 24, 2004, 10:48:15 pm

lol I was just on the Mandy Moore boards and everyone THERE is struggling to get Mandy in a higher position while we're trying to get Vanessa higher....

 :lol:

Title: Mmmh
Post by: saphire on July 27, 2004, 09:28:29 am

I think she wouldn't win definetly, just because she's not one of this" i take my clothe off for every f**in magazine and sing every shit someone would write for me if only its comercial enough". She just an natural talent, not an comercial talent. Shes a real artist not one of this Britney's and Hilary's which lookin cute and wanting evryones attention. American I dol would never worth the playin of an instrument as much as a wonderful and perfect body and Face. Shes not perfct and thats what is so perefect at her, that she dont try it and be as great as a vanessa couls be

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: amberbeads on July 27, 2004, 05:03:00 pm

i'm pretty sure christina would win.
vanessa might hang around for awhile, but i doubt she'd hit the top three even.

Title: If V was on American Idol...would she win????
Post by: BWilli on July 28, 2004, 10:14:10 am

ok...i can understand why peeps like Aguilera have a shitload of votes (of course she'd win)....but how the hell does Taylor Hansen have more votes than V???

i bet it's fixed....just like jeopardy....calm down....i know it's not real