NESSAholics.com
Vanessa Carlton => General Vanessa Carlton Discussion => Topic started by: VanessaCarltonMania on February 08, 2008, 12:10:00 pm
-
Guys...help me with this one... :razz:
My ex-boyfriend is insisting that she isnt Indie....he says she's rock!
And i am insisting that she is Indie or Classical Pop Rock...not just ROCK!
back me up on this people!!! PLZ!!! :? :? :? :( :o
-
i wouldn't say she's indie either, sorry.
i thought she had gone down that route when i heard the snippet of "nolita fairytale" though.
i'd say she was more pop-rock ish...
-
Yeah shes not indie I don't think very much. Be Not Nobody and Harmonium are sometimes referred to as rock on some music places and stuff shes like pop rock.
-
INDIE IS NOT A STYLE OF MUSIC!!!!!!
you're both wrong.
She's a classically trained pianist/singer songwriter.
That's probably the best way to put it.
-
but on her albums she doesn't play classical music. she's piano pop/rock, in my opinion.
-
I'd say shes pop.
-
INDIE IS NOT A STYLE OF MUSIC!!!!!!
you're both wrong.
She's a classically trained pianist/singer songwriter.
That's probably the best way to put it.
i agree, but i prefer to say she is progressive pop...hahahhahahahah...
-
haha "progressive pop"
I like that the best actually.
-
Guys...help me with this one... :razz:
My ex-boyfriend is insisting that she isnt Indie....he says she's rock!
And i am insisting that she is Indie or Classical Pop Rock...not just ROCK!
back me up on this people!!! PLZ!!! :? :? :? :( :o
There are a few things wrong. Firstly, Indie isn't a genre. That's just bullshit. She plays pop music. Whether you like it or not, get over it.
-
i would say shes classical with a voice! lol
-
INDIE IS NOT A STYLE OF MUSIC!!!!!!
you're both wrong.
She's a classically trained pianist/singer songwriter.
That's probably the best way to put it.
HAHAHA
Now that Ive cooled down a little and i started to actually think about it....I AGREE WITH U 100% !!! :D :lol: :lol:
He said she's a band...and i was like NO!!!!
She's a solo piano artist...
and he goes NO SHES ROCK!
being a band doesn't have anything to do with rock...right?
And on her myspace she is described as jazz/pop/rock i think
but i think i just wanted to prove him wrong :oops: :oops: :oops: :razz: :razz: :lol: :lol: :lol: :D
LOL
-
and thanks everyone for setting me straight! :D :razz: :lol:
-
Uhm, she's pop. Simple.
-
it was rock/pop in case of BNN, Harmonium pop/rock, H&T pop :)
that's my opinion
-
I'd say shes pop.
-
You can call it how ever you hear it, but its NOT indie..
I think its pop-rock.
-
Why does it matter?
-
but its NOT indie..
the point is irrelevant. she's signed by a label. therefore, she's not indie. indie isn't a style.. it's a fact - are you on an independent label? are you signed at all? if that's true, you're indie. if you're signed to a major label, you're certainly not indie. indie is short for independent.
-
Yes, Indie is not a style of music, it's a type of a musician related to the recording label, whether is major label or indie label and Vanessa is a major label artist.
I think her genre is mostly pop or classical pop...
-
Why does it matter?
it matters because VanessaCarltonMania asked. now stfu.
-
When I put Heroes and Theives in my computer it's listed as General Pop, Harmonium was Alternative and I can't remember what Be Not Nobody Was but I think it was pop rock.
What songs of Vanessa do you normally play for your boyfriend? He may just have heard a few of her more hard songs.
-
itunes either lists her as pop or rock.
-
classical pop...
but that's not true either. there's really no such thing. just because she's classically trained in piano does not mean that her style is anywhere near classical. that doesn't even make much sense. she's pop, maybe pop/rock, or even alternative, and that's giving her a lot of credit (for harmonium).
-
Ya, I'm not sure about the classical thing tho...She sounds pop and alternative could be the best put for her too...
-
When I put Heroes and Theives in my computer it's listed as General Pop, Harmonium was Alternative and I can't remember what Be Not Nobody Was but I think it was pop rock.
What songs of Vanessa do you normally play for your boyfriend? He may just have heard a few of her more hard songs.
He thought her new songs on H&T were rock......
And to me...that is the farthest from 'rock' that Vanessa could get...
And keep in mind that for my ex-boyfriend...rock is like Metalica, Led Zeplin, and AC/DC....so yeah...thats why i was arguing with him... LOL
But if its alt. rock or pop rock then i would kinda agree...especially for BNN and Harmonium... :razz: :)
But I think that H&T has more of a classical sound to it...so maybe classical pop if theres any such thing...LOL! :lol: :D
-
I've never thought of her as rock...more like orchestra pop. if there is such a thing. ha
-
but its NOT indie..
the point is irrelevant. she's signed by a label. therefore, she's not indie. indie isn't a style.. it's a fact - are you on an independent label? are you signed at all? if that's true, you're indie. if you're signed to a major label, you're certainly not indie. indie is short for independent.
So i say somthing are you agreeing all im sayingn is shes not indie... But i dont see why anybody cares.
-
punctuation would be nice.. that was hard to understand.
i was agreeing with you, but the point is there's no debate; it's a fact that she's signed by a major label and therefore, not indie.
i don't know why anyone cares either, but alas, there's a thread about this.
-
why does this involve so many punctuation marks?