NESSAholics.com

Vanessa Carlton => Vanessa Songs / Lyrics / Sheet Music => Topic started by: jim841 on March 26, 2008, 10:26:46 pm

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: jim841 on March 26, 2008, 10:26:46 pm

It's been exactly six months since we got our ears on the full version of Heroes & Thieves. After six months of listening to the album, let's rank each song from best to least favorite.

Here are the rules:

-- You must rank all 11 tracks from best to least favorite
-- NO TIES. If you must, flip a coin
-- In a few days or a week I will tally the scores (11 pts for 1st, 1 pt for 11th, etc.)


OK, here are mine:

1. Hands On Me
2. More Than This
3. Come Undone
4. Fools Like Me
5. Home
6. Heroes & Thieves
7. The One
8. My Best
9. Nolita Fairytale
10. This Time
11. Spring Street

I would also like to add that after six months, H&T is now my favorite album of the three, even better than Harmonium.

Look forward to seeing everyone's rankings.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: davidjp on March 26, 2008, 11:32:40 pm

1. Heroes & Thieves
2. My Best
3. More Than This
4. Home
5. Come Undone
6. Hands On Me
7. Fools Like Me
8. The One
9. This Time
10. Nolita Fairytale
11. Spring Street

I'm taking into account the album versions of these songs. If i took into account the live versions, I would bump The One and This time up to 5 and 6 respectively. When the album first came out More Than This was my favourite song, but since then, it slipped down a couple of places.

Although Harmonium is still my favourite album.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: feishien on March 27, 2008, 01:55:24 am

Ooh yay!

1. Heroes & Theives
2. Nolita Fairytale
3. Fools Like Me
4. Come Undone
5. Hands on Me
6. My Best
7. The One
8. Home
9. More Than This
10. Spring Street
11. This Time

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: ordinaryday6 on March 27, 2008, 04:48:11 am

1. Fools Like Me
2. Home
3. More Than This
4. Come Undone
5. Heroes & Thieves
6. Hands On Me
7. Nolita Fairytale
8. My Best
9. The One
10. This Time
11. Spring Street

i think. i'm not sure which one i think is worse - this time or spring street. and it was really hard to decide which of the top 3 were the best. and i had a hard time picking whether i thought my best or nf were better.

shrug.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: jekyll on March 27, 2008, 05:02:18 am

1. Heroes & Thieves
2. More Than This
3. Come Undone
4. My Best
5. Home
6. Fools Like Me
7. Nolita Fairytale
8. The One
9. Spring Street
10. This Time
11. Hands On Me
 :D  :D  :D  :D

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Heriol on March 27, 2008, 07:54:53 am

1. More Than This
2. My Best
3. Fools Like Me
4. Home
5. Heroes and Thieves
6. Spring Street
7. The One
8. Hands on Me
9. This Time
10. Nolita Fairytale
11. Come Undone

That's it :D

Title: Results so far -- keep them coming
Post by: jim841 on March 27, 2008, 08:26:12 am

Here are the results after 6 votes... keep your rankings coming!


(http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/3519/screenshot03ah8.jpg)

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: AisforAdrn on March 27, 2008, 10:25:36 am

1.More Than This
2.My Best
3.Heroes and Thieves
4.Nolita Fairytale
5.Hands On Me
6.The One
7.Fools Like Me
8.Home
9.This Time
10.Come Undone
11.Spring Street

:):)

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: maag on March 27, 2008, 11:15:23 am

1. Home
2. Fools Like Me
3. Hands On Me
4. Nolita Fairytale
5. The One
6. My Best
7. Come Undone
8. This Time
9. Heroes & Thieves
10. More Than This
11. Spring Street

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: whitehouses81680 on March 27, 2008, 11:59:09 am

(based on iTunes play count)

1. Spring Street
2. More Than This
3. Come Undone
4. Home
5. My Best
6. The One
7. Hands on Me
8. Fools Like Me
9. Heroes & Thieves
10. This Time
11. Nolita Fairytale

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: SadAsBlue on March 27, 2008, 01:06:08 pm

1)Hands on Me
2)Home
3)Come Undone
4)More Than This
5)Heros and Thieves
6)Fools like Me
7)Nolita Fairytale
8)My Best
9)The One
10)This Time
11)Spring street

This was really hard

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Martin. on March 27, 2008, 01:08:40 pm

01. More Than This
02. My Best
03. Nolita Fairytale
04. Come Undone
05. Hands On Me
06. The One (ft. Stevie Nicks)
07. Fools Like Me
08. Home
09. Spring Street
10. Heroes & Thieves
11. This Time

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Morgan on March 27, 2008, 04:05:54 pm

01 - Home
02 - Heroes and Thieves
03 - My Best
04 - Fools Like Me
05 - More Than This
06 - Come Undone
07 - This Time
08 - Nolita Fairytale
09 - Hands On Me
10 - The One
11 - Spring Street

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: jim841 on March 27, 2008, 04:43:28 pm

Here is a snapshot after 12 votes ... keep the rankings coming.


(http://img291.imageshack.us/img291/9090/screenshot02je6.jpg)

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: itsthefiveofus on March 27, 2008, 05:00:01 pm

1.   My Best
2.   Hands on Me
3.   Nolita Fairytale
4.   Heroes & Thieves
5.   Spring Street
6.   The One
7.   This Time
8.   Fools Like Me
9.   Home
10. Come Undone
11. More Than This

This is my rankings as of now. I am sure it will be all different in a few weeks.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: LadyLavender on March 27, 2008, 06:42:43 pm

1. heroes & thieves
2. fools like me
3. spring street
4. my best
5. more than this
6. home
7. come undone
8. the one
9. this time
10. hands on me
11. nolita fairytale

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: private-radio on March 28, 2008, 09:21:49 am

1) Come Undone
2) Nolita Fairytale
3) Hands on Me
4) My Best
5) Home
6) Fools Like Me
7) More Than This
8) Spring Street
9) Heroes & Thieves
10) The One
11) This Time

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: _all_is_well_ on March 28, 2008, 12:45:20 pm

1. More Than This
2. Nolita Fairytale
3. Heroes and Thieves
4. Home
5. Come Undone
6. Fools Like Me
7. The One
8. Hands On Me
9. Spring Street
10. My Best
11. This Time

These change frequently!

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: saphire on March 30, 2008, 05:29:29 am

1. More than this
2. Heroes and Thieves
3. Come Undone
4. My Best
5. Fools like me
6. The One
7. Hands on me
8. this Time
9. Home
10. Nolita Fairytale
11. Spring Street

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: shinesobright07 on March 30, 2008, 08:12:07 am

1. The One
 2. More than this
 3. Noita Fairytale
 4. Hands on me
 5. This Time
 6. Fools like me
 7. My Best
 8. Spring Street
 9. Heroes and Thieves
 10. Come Undone
 11. Home


 Thanks for posting!!!  :D

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: MyMelody on March 30, 2008, 10:15:23 am

I found it easier to start with my least favorite and work backwards. I don't really know how The One ended up as my favorite.

1. The One
2. Hands on Me
3. Home
4. Fools Like Me
5. More Than This
6. My Best
7. Come Undone
8. Nolita Fairytale
9. Spring Street
10. This Time
11. Heroes & Thieves

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: cassiemoy on March 30, 2008, 07:06:55 pm

1. More than this
2. Hands on me
3. Fools like me
4. Home
5. Spring street
6. Nolita fairytale
7. The one
8. Heroes & thieves
9. This time
10. Come undone
11. My best

whoa, kinda difficult. h&t is very lovable.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: iKnowWhatYouDid on March 30, 2008, 07:36:17 pm

1. Home
2. Hands on Me
3. Fools Like Me
4. More Than This
5. Spring Street
6. Come Undone
7. Heroes & Thieves
8. Nolita Fairytale
9. My Best
10. This Time
11. The One

That took me sooooo long.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Epit on April 01, 2008, 01:58:33 am

Ok here's mine XD

01- Nolita Fairytale
02- Hands On Me
03- My Best
04- Heroes & Thieves
05- Come Undone
06- More Than This
07- Fools Like Me
08- Spring Street
09- This Time
10- Home
11- The One

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: All I Ask2003 on April 01, 2008, 07:27:08 pm

1.  More Than This
2.  Come Undone
3.  Fools Like Me
4.  Heroes & Thieves
5.  Spring Street
6.  My Best
7.  Hands on Me
8.  The One
9.  Nolita Fairytale
10.  Home
11.  This Time

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: lala on April 05, 2008, 01:11:00 pm

01. Home
02. Hands On Me
03. Heroes And Thieves
04. Fools Like Me
05. Nolita Fairytale
06. More Than This
07. Spring Street
08. This Time
09. The One
10. My Best
11. Come Undone

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: HandsOnMe on May 03, 2008, 01:40:51 pm

1. Hands On Me
2. This Time
3. Home
4. The One
5. More Than This
6. Fools Like Me
7. Come Undone
8. Heroes And Thieves
9. My Best
10. Nolita Fairytale
11. Spring Street

My opinions vary from time to time but this is how I feel about H&T now.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: initially_yours on May 06, 2008, 02:53:36 pm

1. Fools Like Me
2. More than This
3.  Home
4. Hands on Me
5. Spring Street
6.  The One
7.This Time
8. Nolita Fairytale
9.  Come Undone
10.  My Best
11.  Heroes and Thieves

I used to like "Heroes and Thieves" but now, not so much.  I dunno why.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Felo on May 06, 2008, 06:34:08 pm

1. More Than This
2. My Best
3. Home
4. Fools Like Me
5. Come Undone
6. Spring Street
7. Hands On Me
8. Heroes & Thieves
9. This Time
10. Nolita Fairytale
11. The One

It took me a while xD the last songs doesn't mean that I don't like them, I just like the first ones better. The only one that I actually skip when I listen the album, is The One.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: iluvvanessa on May 07, 2008, 04:00:38 pm

1. Home-The outro makes me cry it is so beautiful!
2. More Than This
3. Heroes and Thieves
4. Hands On Me
5. Nolita Fairytale
6. Fools Like Me
7. This Time
8. My Best
9. Come Undone
10. The One
11. Spring Street

I LOVE ALL THESE SONGS!!!! Its so hard rating them.

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: cyanyde on May 09, 2008, 10:27:17 pm

1. Spring Street
2. Come Undone
3. My Best
4. Nolita Fairytale
5. The One ~ with Stevie Nicks
6. Heroes and Thieves
7. Home
8. Fools Like Me
10. More Than This

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Kate on May 10, 2008, 04:58:34 am

1 hands on me
2 heroes and thieves
3 nolita fairytale
4 home
5 fools like me
6 more than this
7 the one
8 this time
9 come undone
10 my best
11 spring street

Quote

cyanide, you forgot hands on me! on purpose?  :)

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: darkcarnival13 on May 17, 2008, 11:54:16 am

1.Nolita Fairytale
2.Fools Like Me
3.Hands On Me
4.More Than This
5.Home
6.Spring Street
7.Come Undone
8.This Time
9.Heroes and Thieves
10.The One
11.My Best

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: iluvvanessa on May 18, 2008, 12:46:14 pm

Beautiful siggy darkcarnival13

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: darkcarnival13 on May 18, 2008, 03:14:13 pm

Quote from: "iluvvanessa"

Beautiful siggy darkcarnival13

awwww....thanks :)

Title: Exactly 6 months later -- rank H&T tracks
Post by: Nessaholic4Ever on July 08, 2008, 07:54:26 pm

I've been listening to H&T on my iPod constantly since it came out, so this should be fairly easy.

1. More Than This
2. Heroes & Thieves
3. Fools Like Me
4. Come Undone
5. Spring Street
6. My Best
7. Home
8. This Time
9. The One
10. Hands On Me
11. Nolita Fairytale

But keep in mind, I adore the entire album. So even though NF is on the bottom, I don't dislike it.