I'd bet my life on the fact that Vanessa's piano playing skills are far better than Alicia's.
Personally I've never been able to get into Alicia Keys...I've liked maybe 2 or 3 of her singles, but not enough to even purchase them on itunes. She's overrated and Vanessa is underrated.
I totally agree. I liked Alicia at the beginning but now she's just overrated.
But you guys gotta remember, MTV is trying to go more R&B/Hip-hop & cut off pop completely at least for now so just remember that when you read stuff like that.
before i give my opinion, i would just like to say thank you to whoever posted the article about Alicia Keys, b/c i'm a huge fan of her, and have been for more than 3 years, around the same time i became a fan of Vanessa [i became a fan of hers just 2 months earlier] and the piano.
i disagree. i think as far as techincal piano skills are, i don't really know how good Vanessa really is. i like her music a little more than Alicia's but i think that Alicia is the better piano player, b/c she showcases her skills more than Vanessa in terms of chromatic scales, glissandos, arpeggios, etc. she also adds classical pieces to her shows and albums, which is something that Vanessa never does. i guess she doesn't want to show off.
i don't think that Alicia is really overrated, b/c i think that she's getting the amount of credit that she deserves for her craft, b/c she's a true artist. in fact, i think her talents are more versatile than Vanessa's, b/c she channels them in more areas. she even improvises more than Van. why Vanessa get more credit for her artistry, i don't really know. i guess it's b/c her music's too Indie for mainstream attention, no offense. Hanson's a very talented band, too, but also underrated b/c they're an Indie band, and mainstream doesn't really welcome that kind of genre with open arms.
if you don't like Alicia, then that's fine; i can see why. but i like her, also, even though i like Vanessa's music more.