Haha wow, I can't believe anyone on this board actually shares my opinion. I'm not even religious, so that's not my firewall. I'm agnostic at best, and I still think that for the purpose of clarity (mostly) and tradition (somewhat), "marriage" the word and the exact legal union stipulated within the definition, should remain male and female only. It has nothing to do with discrimination, and everything to do with - why the heck can't they just have their own word for it and call it a day?
Garriage people, GARRIAGE. Learn it and love it =)
Gay people, such as myself, don't want another word for "marriage" because it's about equality. You know, in the constitution it states that all men are created equal and such, remember? So since we're all equal according to the constitution, why do we need another goddamn word for the same exact thing. :roll:
I don't know, why do we need another word for murder when it's performed on a Gay person than when it's performed on a straight person?
Or maybe you want to get rid of "hate crime" too?
Why do we need a different set of laws for hiring and firing gay people than for hiring and firing straight people? Or maybe you want to get rid of discrimination laws that specifically list sexual preference too?
Why do we need a different word for men who have sex with men and men who have sex with women? We should just call them all "sexual" right?
You use different words to distinguish things that are different.
I don't think we should have a new legal definition, but I am OK with society giving it a new name to differentiate.
Murder is still murder, motivations for murder however, are different. If a gay individual is murdered during a robbery for the purpose of aquiring their money, it's not a hate a crime. It only becomes a hate crime when that gay individual is murdered
because they're gay. Those are two very different scenarios. If someone is killed for their sexuality, gender, race, etc. - that's a hate crime. Which is different from other acts of murder.
You don't always need another word for when a gay person is murdered. You only need another word (hate crime) when a gay person is murdered because of a hate crime. Not all gay people killed are murdered because of hate crimes, and not all of their murder's are labeled as such. Your statement makes no sense at all.
Saying that marriage, between two people whom love one another, should be given a different name when it's
not different from any other type of union between a man and woman, is a pretty moronic statement. If you're straight or gay, it fucking doesn't matter, marriage is still marriage. The act of marriage, the recognition of marriage, the financial benefits that married couples receieve from the government, are all the same. The only thing that is different, are the people being married, but marriage itself still hasn't changed.
So there's no need to differentiate marriage between two men and marriage between a man and a woman. So there's no need for another word, because marriage itself hasn't changed.
Men that have sex with other men are given a different name because the act of sex they perform is different from the act of sex a man and woman would perform. Gay sex, and straight sex, are different. So yes, we need different labels because guess what, they're actually different things. Again, your statement makes no sense.
Marriage itself and what it intales isn't different. That's my point.
The amount of flawed logic in your post baffles me.