Lindsey Lohan vs. Hilary Duff

[Holly]

These two have a rivalry going... So I thought I'd make a poll for them.

I choose Lindsey cause Hilary annoys me. Plus, Lindsey is a better actress and I've only heard Hilary sing, but I'm sure Lindsey couldnt be worse than her at that either. Or maybe she could, and then it's a good thing she doesnt, or if she does that I havent heard it.

[keith]

I see this whole "rivalry" as being stupid.

I like Hilary's music and Lindsay's movies. So I guess I like them both.

[rosieposy87]

okay lets weight things up here:

Hilary duff basically played HERSELF on a tv show.
Lindsay Lohan played twins by herself who spoke to each other, and still managed to pull it off.

Hilary duff's voice sounds bad even when its been electronically altered.
Linday's voice is at least presentable.

Hilary duff's voice goes up at the end of every bloody sentence.
Lindsay can at least speak coherantly.

Hilary duff looks like your typical blonde girl.
Lindsay Lohan is pretty.

There ya GO! You know who i'm chosing!

[jlmusicchick]

Lindsay Lohan. she just seems more relatable than hilary duff - hilary's tooooooooo perfect, ya know? although i don't think lindsay can really sing at all....but that's just me :-P

[Scotty]

hehe

But I picked Lindsey, but i just think thats so funny, I imagine her talking in those words in a sarcastic tone 8O

[Vultch]

Lindsey is legal next month.
I'll vote then :wink:

[Scotty]

coughstypicalcoughs

[Jophess]

Lindsey. She is a better singer (although not a great one) anjd a better actor. And she doesn't have an older sister who looks up to her. o_O *shakes fist at Haylie Duff*

[keith]

The reasons people have for not liking Hilary Duff are so lame  :roll:  There are so many jealous haters out there.

[Holly]

Lindsey sings? haha, what?

[emmy]

Lindsey sings? haha, what?

yeah, I can't remember when, but I know I've heard her sing, and I don't mean in a movie.  somewhere else.  shes not that great, but neither is hilary.  so imho they both stink at singing by lindseys the better actress, so that is who I voted for.

[Steveau]

and Lindsay has a hellluva body.  8O

[JazzyManda]

Lindsey can actually play the guitar. Hillary sings bad... hmmm
i'm going with Lindsey or however you spell her name

Amanda

[LimeTwister]

okay lets weight things up here:

Hilary duff basically played HERSELF on a tv show.
Lindsay Lohan played twins by herself who spoke to each other, and still managed to pull it off.

Hilary duff's voice sounds bad even when its been electronically altered.
Linday's voice is at least presentable.

Hilary duff's voice goes up at the end of every bloody sentence.
Lindsay can at least speak coherantly.

Hilary duff looks like your typical blonde girl.
Lindsay Lohan is pretty.

There ya GO! You know who i'm chosing!

Who would of ever thought that I was thinking the exact same thing!?

[Holly]

oh yeah... she sang in that movie where they switch places, i forgot the name, now i remember! but i can't remember if she was good or not.