American Idol 4

[amberbeads]

soo yeah i love constantine, mario and anwar

I looooove Constantine he's so adorable, I love his rock star vibe :-)
I thought Mario did poorly tonight, I totally disagreed with the judges.
Bo was so good! I thought he did a great job with that song, it was perfect.

[B]

I liked Scott and Anwar tonight. Bo did well. I wasn't terribly impressed with David, but I know he is better than he showed. I am thinking at least one of if not two of Joseph, Jared, or Travis is going home.

[aleera84]

We get American Idol in about 2 weeks so we will be so far behind but I think that is because The X factor has just started over here.
Ah I hope I don't get obsessed like I did with Australian Idol 2.

[BWilli]

a lot of poor song choices last night.

Anwar was really good, as well as Bo.

I agreed with Simon on Mario's performance.  His voice seemed off, however he's very entertaining.

I'd say that Jared Yates, Anthony Federov and Travis Tucker might be in the lowest.  I think Jared is definately going home.  Federov and Tucker are normally good, but were pretty bad last night.

[B]

a lot of poor song choices last night.

Anwar was really good, as well as Bo.

I agreed with Simon on Mario's performance.  His voice seemed off, however he's very entertaining.

I'd say that Jared Yates, Anthony Federov and Travis Tucker might be in the lowest.  I think Jared is definately going home.  Federov and Tucker are normally good, but were pretty bad last night.

Definitely, there were a lot of poor song choices.

And I wasn't terribly impressed by Anthony, but I figured he'd make it through for what he's done so far and his personal story, I am sure that itself is getting him some votes.

[Kiya]

Guess what starts here in 2 weeks.

We got ur idol 3, and now getting ur idol 4. Never got your Idol 1 or 2 though.

I dunno how its gonna work, coz xfactor has started, Big Brother starts in may, Aus Idol 3 starts this year as well...and they are all on the same channel...

ahh well its all good.

[amberbeads]

Almost all the girls did poorly last night, imo.
How the fuck could they praise Mikayla? She talked half the time, she didn't sing, and her voice was off when she did!! This was her worst performance thus far, and I'm with Simon about the amusing/annoying thing. She is so fucking obnoxious.

[BWilli]

Carrie Underwood and Nadia Turner are the two best girl singers.

Janay Castine was terrible, and she didnt look right singing last night....she was very stiff...i'd say she's one of the girls going home


and this Melinda girl.  Randy says she's the best vocalist...to be honest, I think last night was the first time i've seen her in this competition, and I was NOT impressed at all....but I think she'll be around for another week.

[amberbeads]

Yeah Janay did soooo poorly I almost felt sorry for her. She looked so nervous and she chose the wrong song and sang it badly. That sucks

[BWilli]

eh...for shits and giggles...here's the top 12 I like (I'm expecting at least two of my top 12 not to make it...of course it could always be more)

Anwar Robinson
Scott Savol
Mario Vazquez
David Brown
Constantine Maroulis
Bo Bice
Carrie Underwood
Nadia Turner
Lindsey Cardinale
Mikalah Gordon
Amanda Avila
Aloha Mischeaux

[keith]

Best episode ever.

Thank you so so so much FOX for the early birthday present of getting that dreadful Judd Harris off my TV.

I don't know why Melinda Lira was so shocked. She totally sucked and she knew it.

Nadia Turner has rather unimpressive vocals to me and she looks like a man.

[BWilli]

Nadia Turner has rather unimpressive vocals to me and she looks like a man.

weird...i kinna thought so too....she has the facial features of Urkle....that really scares me.  i still think she can sing.

I'm not surprised the Samantha was voted off.  I am surprised that Janay wasn't voted off.  She should be thanking her lucky stars.

and again...this Melinda girl.  She's got a decent voice, but not this week.  oh well.  she wasn't in my top 12 anyway   :razz:

I knew Jared would go....I didn't think that Judd would get voted off (not this week atleast), his style of song chossing reminds me of John Peter Lewis from last year....entertaining a little, but not the best singer, oh well....he wasn't in my top 12 anyway   :razz:

[keith]

I am surprised that Janay wasn't voted off.  She should be thanking her lucky stars.

Oh Brian, don't tell me this show still surprises you.  Janay pulled a Jasmine Trias (by almsot crying after she performed) and got what we cynics call "the sympathy vote." Voters felt sorry for Janay because she was so nervous and thought she deserved a second chance. This happened in AI3 when Jasmine had case of the shakes and bombed horribly. She starting weeping after Simon ripped into her. She got the sympathy vote and LaToya was booted the next night.

[BWilli]

She got the sympathy vote and LaToya was booted the next night.

i guess the only difference this time is that some one almost as bad was kicked off, and not one of the best...

shit...in a way, i'm glad she's still around, i want to see if she can prove herself next week

[Jophess]

Nadia Turner challenged Jake Simpson on Star Search and he easily won.

The two guys I voted for were voted off. And go Makaylah!