Look everybody- Vinyl's are better! Ask you dad! Seriously though you'd rather listen to Sgt. Peppers on vinyl than c.d and it just gives a different feel listening to it on a record and it can't be beat!
It's nostalga. People have been listening to that music in that format far longer than they have been listening to it in a digital format. They like the harmonic distortion and such present in the older equipment and formats. I can understand people wanting to listen to older stuff on vinyl. It's part of the sound. Just don't claim that vinyl is technically superior to modern digital stuff, because it 'aint.
What got me in this thread is that Vanessa's stuff has been recorded and mastered in digital. The target format is CD. Any vinyl release will be of lower quality than the original CD. If I want all the distortion and noise, I have effects processors I can use to recreate that. *yawn*. Vinyl releases of newer stuff are wastes of money, unless you scratch.
I don't even know where to begin! Ha Ha! ANY recording introduces a coloration of sound, and sound is so objective. I have lived through the digital revolution long enough to know that vinyl, CD's, DVD-Audio's, DAT's, SACD's, etc. are limited by the quality of what goes in(i.e. garbage in, garbage out) and what can really make or break an album's sound is the MASTERING. So many albums these days are compressed all to hell(ex. listen to Private Radio, omg is it over EQ'd or what?) in something called by some industry types as "the loudness wars". Nuff said about that.
How can a statement be made like "any vinyl release will be lower quality than the original CD"? How many A/B comparisons have actually been made? I'm willing to bet not too many. To have a preference is one's right; to generalize just shows a lack of knowledge.
Don't be so sure VC's tracks are all digital. And if you listen to a track like "C'est La Vie", you'll hear the sound of either analog tape or a REAL noisy mic pre. That sure wasn't cut on Pro Tools HD.
To be sure, there are bad recordings, both analog and digital. I happen to still like vinyl, though ALL formats irk me. Sure, the pops, clicks, and inner groove distortion pee me off, but there is still a musical thing happening there. I've recorded directly into Pro Tools, and it just stinks on ice. I don't exactly know why. My Panasonic DAT just blows it away.
It's been said that digital is only slices of an analog signal, and everything must end up analog anyway, till someone can figure out how to get ones and zeros to come out of one's speakers. Who knows? Just enjoy the MUSIC. And I'm all over that Vanessa vinyl!
Peace,
Dan/NS