New article, kind of bad...

[nosticker]

:roll:  Oh, I TOTALLY buy that he is/was a promoter or promo guy.  Most of them are a dime a dozen, and about as disposable as shirts.  And when they answer a third-rate blog, it makes one wonder what work they're really doing.  My guess? Watching Judge Mathis.

So this reviewer doesn't get it.  So what?  There is no one artist that everyone gets, not even The Beatles or Beethoven or you name it.  Criticism of my fave artists used to make me nuts, but now I could not care less if someone else likes something I like or not.


Dan/NS

[tylor2000]

She is obviously worth more than the time of day to them.

Next Reviewer!

[Butz]

OMG what the fuck is this shit, and then that comment from a "former A&M promoter"!

The reviewer is just a cynic asshole, must be frustrating. Suffer along!

[PianoGirl4444]

:roll:  Oh, I TOTALLY buy that he is/was a promoter or promo guy.  Most of them are a dime a dozen, and about as disposable as shirts.  And when they answer a third-rate blog, it makes one wonder what work they're really doing.  My guess? Watching Judge Mathis.

So this reviewer doesn't get it.  So what?  There is no one artist that everyone gets, not even The Beatles or Beethoven or you name it.  Criticism of my fave artists used to make me nuts, but now I could not care less if someone else likes something I like or not.


Dan/NS

The only reason it upsets me is because of the people reading it.  He can hate her all he wants, but when people read that, they're not going to want to check out her new music.  Lots of people just can't think for themselves!!

[nosticker]

:roll:  Oh, I TOTALLY buy that he is/was a promoter or promo guy.  Most of them are a dime a dozen, and about as disposable as shirts.  And when they answer a third-rate blog, it makes one wonder what work they're really doing.  My guess? Watching Judge Mathis.

So this reviewer doesn't get it.  So what?  There is no one artist that everyone gets, not even The Beatles or Beethoven or you name it.  Criticism of my fave artists used to make me nuts, but now I could not care less if someone else likes something I like or not.


Dan/NS

The only reason it upsets me is because of the people reading it.  He can hate her all he wants, but when people read that, they're not going to want to check out her new music.  Lots of people just can't think for themselves!!

I get you, but it's not as if he is some kind of uber-critic who has credibility.  30 years ago, there were critics with names that had some kind of pull or following.   Today, we have dickheads with laptops that blog.  Whoop-de-doo.  That page probably has less hits than the Jets defensive line.

She's had great writeups in major publications.  This one means nothing.
Real music fans---whom I believe comprise 99% of her audience---will not take this seriously.

Dan/NS

[Butz]

He's not Perez, that's a fact!

[emil0ca]

I DO think Vanessa takes herself too seriously sometimes, but guy is delusional if he thinks it doesn't bug her to have to play the ONLY song she is known for. Anyone would have that reaction.

Is this actually a review or just some guy blogging about a concert he went to? Weiiiiiiird.

[Nessaholista]

"Don’t get me wrong: “A Thousand Miles” is..."

 :lol:

We're ALL get HIM wrong, right?

[All I Ask2003]

It’s also quite obvious that Vanessa Carlton didn’t learn, from Mariah Carey.

Even I know there's not supposed to be a comma after "learn".
Since when has Vanessa only worn jean shorts (don't think I've ever seen that anyway) or jeans with masculine clothes?
Lol yeah she's a real tomboy in her Victorian-inspired outfits.

[rosieposy87]

:roll:  Oh, I TOTALLY buy that he is/was a promoter or promo guy.  Most of them are a dime a dozen, and about as disposable as shirts.  And when they answer a third-rate blog, it makes one wonder what work they're really doing.  My guess? Watching Judge Mathis.

So this reviewer doesn't get it.  So what?  There is no one artist that everyone gets, not even The Beatles or Beethoven or you name it.  Criticism of my fave artists used to make me nuts, but now I could not care less if someone else likes something I like or not.


Dan/NS

The only reason it upsets me is because of the people reading it.  He can hate her all he wants, but when people read that, they're not going to want to check out her new music.  Lots of people just can't think for themselves!!

I get you, but it's not as if he is some kind of uber-critic who has credibility.  30 years ago, there were critics with names that had some kind of pull or following.   Today, we have dickheads with laptops that blog.  Whoop-de-doo.  That page probably has less hits than the Jets defensive line.

She's had great writeups in major publications.  This one means nothing.
Real music fans---whom I believe comprise 99% of her audience---will not take this seriously.

Dan/NS

Exactly. We shouldn't pay this guy any attention at all. How happy would you be if you were some random blogger and suddenly you realised loads of people had read your article (no matter how bad it is)? Your head grows. So let him write all he wants.

The A&M guy thing is HILARIOUS. I'm SO sure it's real.  :roll:

[craft]

It’s also quite obvious that Vanessa Carlton didn’t learn, from Mariah Carey.

Even I know there's not supposed to be a comma after "learn".
Since when has Vanessa only worn jean shorts (don't think I've ever seen that anyway) or jeans with masculine clothes?
Lol yeah she's a real tomboy in her Victorian-inspired outfits.

LOL. She's a regular Sinead 'O Conner in those Victorian dresses. I noticed that comma too. Nearly tore me apart to read it, considering I write novels and stories for a hobby.

[Imaginary Ocean]

That's is so MEAN !!!! and I love Jewel....

Poor Vanessa, really hope she won't pay any attention to this !

[Boy of Summer]

Wow.

What a terrible, shitty, immature and lackluster review.

This lame excuse of a dried chunk of dogshit deserves a nice swift kick in the ass.

[VaderDawsn]

Did this person see the VC or an someone else? I mean I've seen her twice live and I FELT the emotional connection....

[me and my piano---tim]

Wow I'm sorry but that article is so funny! I mean it's kinda entertaining to see someone make fun of her.  It's not like this guy's opinion matters.