Andrew, great job! I really enjoyed that. Been awhile since I've read something that had me hooked in expectation of what will happen/be said next. (If it was only a novel!)
Anyways, people pretty much said the things I was going to say like about the typos and bad wording... such as: ...the same parties you that we went to.... that often happen when backspacing a couple times trying to get the right effect on what is being said.... Just fix those things. And as far as telling more about Jenna... I wouldn't. I agree, I like figuring things out. But thats why I wish this was a novel (are you going to keep going with it and write a book or keep it a short story and end it as it is?) ... because then I would be able to figure out with time whether Jenna is a whore or if James is so filled up with ego that he all of a sudden feels more powerful over her. I would love to learn who the other guy was, what sort of things that James apparently caught Jenna and him doing, more backflashing of James and Jenna's romantic past, etc... But that all can only come if you do more....
lol
Oh, and one more thing I'm kinda lost on:
-Five, for the five months we didn’t talk to each other.
-Was that why I saw you with HIM downtown last weekend?
-He had been waiting a week for this, he could wait a few more minutes.
Why the jagged jump from five months to a week? It seems okay if you figure that they're relationship was going awry (sp?) for sometime but there isn't anything to hint towards it.... Just seems that all of a sudden the guy wants to hurt her after all the years? that he "just wanted to make her happy." I suppose that could portray built up resentment for not being good enough, but it could perhaps be shown a tad through a sentence or two.... ?
Oh: "She needed to hear this and he needed to hear what she had to say." What was she suppose to say? She never really did say much that had to do with what he was saying... The only thing she said was that she just wanted to make him better.... I dunno. It just seems to be missing something. Something that I was expecting her to say, like pleading to him for forgiveness or something drastic and even patheticly (in James opinion which could therefore be sent to the readers)...
I really did enjoy this and you can write very well, very discriptive and detailed... I loved it! Hope to hear more!